Skip navigation.

Analytic Zen

Consciousness, analytic philosophy, zen meditation.

Blind Forces

, ,

John Searle, in describing a common reaction to the description of free will, notes that "we sense alternative possibilities open. We sense that there are genuine choices available to us, that we don't have to just sit back and watch blind forces operate. That's why we have a problem of free will"

We sense that we can choose the red wine or the white wine, rather than saying "since everything is deterministic, I'll just wait to see what happens" and thereby ordering nothing.


Searle's description of our experience: "We sense there are genuine choices available to us, that we don't have to just sit back and watch blind forces operate."

Our mistake is to accept as a real alternative this idea of "sitting back and watching" deterministic processes, since this is to accept an impossible or supernatural detachment. When the blind forces are within us, we have no such ability to step back; we ARE the blind forces.

Bodhisattva teaching in the Kwan Um School of Zen

, , ,

Zen Master Seung Sahn on Bodhisattva action (from the book Dropping Ashes on the Buddha):

No-attachment thinking means that your mind is clear all the time. When you drive, you aren't thinking; you are just driving. The truth is just like this. Red light: stop. Green light means go. It is intuitive action. Intuitive action means acting without desire or attachment. My mind is clear like a mirror, reflecting everything just as it is. Red comes and the mirror is red. White comes and the mirror is white. This is how a Bodhisattva lives. I have no desires for myself. My actions are for all people.

If you attain enlightenment, you will understand that all people are suffering greatly, so your mind will also be suffering. This is Big Suffering. So you must enter the great Bodhisattva way and save all people from their suffering. I hope you only keep a don't-know-mind always & everywhere. Then you will attain enlightenment and save all beings.

Natural-style living is good. Plastic-style living is good. Business-style living is also good. What is important is WHY you are living this way. If you desire money & objects for yourself or if you desire nature for yourself then this is no good. If you cut off your desires, then business is not business. It is Bodhisattva business. Working and earning money in order to help other people, this is Zen business. Only interested in making money and being successful for myself is "small I". But if I make money to help all people then this is good business. This is "Big Business!"

-----------------------------------

Zen Master Wu Kwang on the Bodhisattva Vows:
http://www.kwanumzen.org/primarypoint/v03n2-1986-spring-wkzm-carryingsnowinateaspoon.html

Q: Every morning I get up with everyone else here and take a vow to save all sentient beings from suffering. How can I do that?

ZMWK: Do you want to do it?

Q: Yes.

ZMWK: Then you'll find a way, through getting up every morning and taking that vow. That's an impossible vow. Each one of these is an impossible vow. "The Buddha way is inconceivable - I vow to attain it." How do you attain something that's inconceivable? "Sentient beings are numberless, I vow to save them all." How? It brings up the image of some great social worker in the sky - (laughter) - bigger than the whole universe, going to save all beings from suffering.

Bernard Tetsugen Glassman Sensei, a teacher in Maezumi Roshi's school (he has a group in New York) gave an example of what a bodhisattva is. He said, there's a well that's dry down on the plains, and up on the mountain tops there is snow. So the bodhisattva is like a guy who decides he'll fill the well by bringing the snow down to the plains, but the only thing he has to carry the snow in is a teaspoon. So he goes up the mountain, gets one teaspoon full of snow, comes back down to the plains and puts the snow in the well. Then he goes back up the mountain, gets another teaspoon full of snow, brings it down and puts it in the well, over and over.

That's a ridiculous endeavor. Never in a million years is he going to fill up that well, but what's important is his sincerity of effort - to just do something, whether it's possible or impossible. That effort, that spirit, is a contribution in and of itself that can't be compared to anything else, so it has absolute value. Because it can't be compared to anything else, the spirit of that fills the universe in one second. At each moment that we do that, all sentient beings are saved, because we affirm the absolute value of everything.

We have to do something, even if it's not possible. So the vow points to something like that.

Q: What is absolute value?

ZMWK: Relative value is concerned with, "This is good," or "This is not as good as something else." Value is ascribed to something based on a comparison with something else. "My watch is better than your watch, so it's worth more." That's relative value. Absolute value has no basis like that. We can't compare with anything, so it stands on its own just as it is. Sometimes we say subject and object become one - pfft! At that time, there's no comparison of anything with anything else, so the absolute value of something emerges at that point. It just stands or sits on its own.

Q: Your story about the bodhisattva with the teaspoon reminds me of a similar story of the sparrow who tries to put out a forest fire by carrying water in his beak. I told that story to one of my friends and they said, "That's the dumbest thing! Why didn't he take a bucket?"

ZMWK: He didn't have a bucket. But we're not talking about mountains and snow, we're talking about suffering. You can't use a power tool on suffering.

Q: I get the feeling sometimes that the sparrow was really dumb.

ZMWK: Yes, sure! But dumbness has its place too. Someone might have a really simple kind of faith which is kind of dumb, given what we see all around us, and yet the energy that might come out of that effort might be quite profound. That doesn't mean we shouldn't sometimes look at the instruments we're using. If there's a bucket at hand and you're using a teaspoon, then that's stupidity. But if there's no bucket and you won't choose the teaspoon because there's no bucket, then that's stupidity, too.

We talk about saving all sentient beings, every morning when we get up and bow and say our vows. But to have the idea that this little congregation of people here is doing something so profound that it's going to make a dent in the social fabric of this country is, from one perspective, dumb. Yet this is the instrument we have at hand, so we make use of it.

---------------------------------

Zen Master Seung Sahn's "Action Zen"
Consists of 4 elements that have become synonymous with Kwan Um Zen School style:

1) it displays his genius in translating classic Ch'an insights into sound bites: his phrases "only don't know", "put it all down", "don't make anything" and "just do it" have become popular parts of American Zen culture

2) it has shifted the emphasis from striving for liberation to "together action", a more socially engaged format, encapsulated by his phrase "How can I help you?" which he exhorts his students to use as a rallying cry for their "Zen boddhisattva" practice

3) his emphasis on "bodhisattva action" replicates in America the pastor-parishioner relationship in Korean Buddhism

4) his use of either koans or mantras as practice tools for Zen training; while confusing for many of his American students, this is a continuation of the mix of Pure Land and Ch'an practices that have dominated Korean Buddhism for several hundred years

His approach to the boddhisattva path is reflective of the popular Korean Buddhist culture where all middle-aged women working in the monasteries are addressed as "bosal nim" (Korean for bodhisattva), and pays no heed to the doctrinal foundations of the bodhisattva path as articulated in the Mahayana sutras where bodhisattvahood is the culminating experience of a lifetime of rigorous perfection of the paramitas.

Zen at the movies

, ,

This is this! This isn't something else, this is this!
- Robert DeNiro (Michael) in The Deer Hunter

Fuck you. Thats my name.
I drive an eighty-thousand dollar BMW. That's my name. And your name is you're wanting.
I made $970,000 last year. How much you make? You see pal, thats who I am, and you're nothing.
- Alec Baldwin (Blake) in Glengarry Glen Ross

There is no 'try'... only 'do'.
- Frank Oz (Yoda) in Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back

This happens...
This is something that happens...
This is something that happens...
- Jeremy Blackman (Stanley) in Magnolia

Student 1: That's a blue shirt.
Student 2: This is a blue shirt.
Student 1: That's a blue shirt.
Student 2: This is a blue shirt.
etc.
- students practicing a foundational technique in Sanford Meisner's Masters Class for actors

... human beings define their reality through suffering...
- Agent Smith (Hugo Weaving) in The Matrix

Huatou - the diamond sword

BACKGROUND
Hua-Tou (or huatou) in Chinese means 'word head' or 'sentence head'. In Ch'an (Zen) it is that which occurs just before a thought arises in the mind; the state of awareness before the mind is disturbed by thoughts about that awareness.

An example from my own experience is the act of reading signs as I walk or drive by: I used to always read the sign to myself in my mind, speaking the words to myself. One day I tried just looking, not thinking about the words, and I still understood the signs. That moment of awareness looking at the sign was the 'sentence head' before my mind started thinking about the awareness (speaking to itself unnecessarily).

When one uses a huatou for practice, the most important thing is to give rise to a doubt sensation. This is manifested by a question-style huatou which cannot be answered through reasoning. (In this way a huatou is similar to a koan).

Examples of huatou recognized by Chan Masters as being effective:
  • What is wu? (i.e. What is emptiness? What is no-self?)
  • Who is dragging this corpse around?
  • What is my original face before my parents were born?
  • Who/What is [bowing/sitting/perceiving/being mindful] now?


In Ch'an (Zen) huatou practice, one first counts breaths or does some other mindfulness meditation in order to concentrate and focus the mind. Then, once the mind is keenly aware and free of most wandering thoughts one can make use of a huatou to give rise to the "great mass of doubt." When this mass of doubt eventually breaks apart, what is revealed is wisdom (the fundamental nature of things).

THE DIAMOND SWORD
If a practitioner does not have great determination and willpower to embark on and sustain practice, then he will not be able to complete the path. A true practitioner is determined enough to sever vexations and attachments, like a warrior facing ten thousand enemies. We should straightaway take up the burden of practice, and whatever we confront we should face it fully. If we make a mistake, there is no regret. We take up this responsibility fully. When you take up the method, apply it directly and move forward without regret. Otherwise, in the slightest doubt or suspicion the ten thousand enemies will defeat you. ("Is this method right for me? I've been using it for half a day now and nothing is happening. Maybe I should try something else.")

Instead of dashing forward, sword in hand to confront the enemy, you start thinking about this or that reason why you should not. With these 2nd thoughts you'll be vanquished right then and there.

So, when it comes to practice, do not doubt whether the method is right for you. Pick up your weapon and advance. And remember: the ten thousand enemies are not outside your own mind. They are your own wandering thoughts, your clinging, your opinions, desires, repulsions, your commentaries, you name it.

Fortunately, the sword you have in your hand, your huatou, is no ordinary sword; it is able to cut through delusions with one swift stroke. The safest way to confront the ten thousand enemies in your mind is to pick up that sword and without blinking an eye slash your way through - just cut them down. And then you will be safe. Otherwise, if you hesitate ("Should I really kill this delusion?") you will be defeated. And what are these delusions? They are any thoughts that are not your huatou.

Zen Teachings of Master Lin Chi

, , ,

According to expounders of sutras and treatises, the many-faceted body is some kind of ultimate goal. But as I see it, that's not so. This multiply-faceted body is nothing but names, or multiple types of dependencies. One man of early times said, 'The body depends on doctrine for its definition, and the land is discussed in terms of the reality.' This 'body' of the Dharma-realm, or reality, and this 'land' of the Dharma-realm we can see clearly are no more than flickering lights.
- Ch'an Master Lin Chi (from "The Zen Teachings of Master Lin-Chi" translated by Burton Watson)

There is no stability in the world; it is like a house on fire. This is not a place where you can stay for a long time. The murderous demon of impermanence is instantaneous, and it does not choose between the upper and lower classes, or between the young and old. If you want to be no different from the Buddhas and Zen masters, just don't seek externally. The pure light in a moment of awareness in your mind is the Buddha's essence within you.
- Ch'an Master Lin Chi (translated by Thomas Cleary)

Moments of Zen

, , ,

When practicing, one needs to have a bold & persevering mind as if your parents have just died.
- Zen Master Xuyun (1839 - 1959)

"Once there were brook trout in the streams in the mountains. You could see them standing in the amber current where the white edges of their fins wimpled softly in the flow. They smelled of moss in your hand. Polished and muscular and torsional. On their backs were vermiculate patterns that were maps of the world in its becoming. Maps and mazes. Of a thing which could not be put back. Not be made right again. In the deep glens where they lived all things were older than man and they hummed of mystery."
- Cormac McCarthy (The Road)

By asking about my style, I know your style.
- Zen Master Joshu (a.k.a. Chou Chou) (788 - 897)

Zen practice pursued within activity is a million times superior to that pursued within tranquility.
- Zen Master Hakuin (1686 - 1769)

Finding quiet in the quiet is easy. Finding quiet in the noisy is what's important.
- Zen Master Seung Sahn (1927 - 2004)

Sometimes you are away from your home yet not on the path, and sometimes you are on the path yet not far from home. With a shout, define guest and host and cast away the thousand worlds.
- Zen Master Bassui (1327 - 1387)