Skip navigation.

Sign up | Lost password? | Help

A CMS to avoid?

, , , , , , ,

I just had to write about this CMS I just bumped into: Zimplit. It seems to be very, very new. It also has probably the easiest install of any CMS - just copy two files onto your web server.

The reason it's that easy is simple - most of the complexity is handled via off-site JavaScript. The single PHP file is simply the conduit to access your web site files.

Zimplit needs no database - it creates standard HTML pages. Templating consists of you creating your own HTML file. New pages start off as copies of existing pages. It is really very basic. No blog support, no gallery support.

None of that is what prompted me to write this post, though. No, the reason is that I'm sad. It's the Javascript code that's making me sad. You see, Opera is blocked from the WYSIWYG editing features - only IE and Firefox are supported. And I mean Firefox. Seamonkey and any other non-Firefox Gecko browser is also blocked. So is any Webkit-based browser like Safari and Chrome. BTW, an "IE" browser is any browser that claims support for "document.all".

Yep, it's crappy browser sniffing time again. :frown: Anyone who promotes the idea of feature detection instead of browser sniffing would be running around in little circles screaming and pulling their hair out right about now.

There are at least two WYSIWYG editors around that are much better - TinyMCE and FCKeditor. Why the Zimplit guys felt they had to reinvent the wheel and then make such a hash of it I don't know.

Apart from all that, what kills Zimplit for me is the dependency on the off-site JS and images. An international communications glitch would leave me unable to edit my site. Or the company could disappear.

Zimplit has too much going wrong now, and potentially far too much going wrong in the future. One to avoid, I think.

Web site photo galleries16GB microSD

Comments

mattiaslepp 28. September 2008, 18:57

We are working hard to make support for Opera, Safari and Chrome. Also standalone version of Zimplit will be ready in one month. Until then is possible to download editor from Zimplit download page. The idea of Zimplit is to keep it very simple for user. As we developing it every day, it s too complicated for user to install updates every day or even every moth new version. Anyway its good to get feedback and ... we try harder.

_Grey_ 29. September 2008, 14:29

@mattiaslepp: "working hard" is so easy to say. How hard is it to use feature detection instead of browser detection? Sorry, this argument is absolute nonsense in my book. "Working hard" doesn't cut it. And it's not simplicity for the user, it is simplicity for the cms developers to use such code. Users get frustrated by this.

Andrew Gregory 30. September 2008, 12:34

There are no excuses for sniffing for Firefox as opposed to Gecko. None whatsoever. As _Grey_ said, rather than making things simple for the user, it's making things more complicated. Browsers like Seamonkey that should be working with the Zimplit code are not.

I will agree that the idea of hosting the bulk of Zimplit code off-site will really simplify management and updating of the system. That will be a great selling point for some people, but it just isn't what *I* would want.

Write a comment

You must be logged in to write a comment. If you're not a registered member, please sign up.

December 2009
S M T W T F S
November 2009January 2010
1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31