I have been running ubuntu 11.10 since beta1 and apart from a few niggling issues. CCSM and misbehaving unity launcher being my personal foes. Recently things had settled down into a completely usable system. So I thought it was time to break it again.
Immediately, I thought, load
gnome-shell that should do it. My experience of running the gnome3 desktop under the gnome2 based ubuntu 11.04 had been, ...erm 'unfavorable'. I don't want to seem like a Unity fan-boy here either, as I have used gnome3 desktop in Fedora 15 and liked it, but I didn't get a fair chance to access its usability over a period of time. I have been using Ubuntu's Unity desktop since 11.04 was launched and have adopted it as my favorite gnome desktop. That mainly comes down to the fact I prefer Ubuntu as my operating system and Unity has become their default desktop and I have been to lazy to change it.
Anyway, probably because ubuntu 11.10 is now gnome3 native, it turned out installing the Gnome3 desktop is now as easy a searching for 'gnome-shell' in Ubuntu's software centre and clicking install. It even worked flawlessly. On reboot I simply logged in to the gnome desktop and 'low-and-behold' there appeared before me a functioning gnome3 desktop in Ubuntu.
I have decided to use gnome-shell for the next week before I make any hard and fast opinions, but, so far it feels very alien. It does seem, however, faster than Unity.
Here is my week with gnome-shell:
Day 1I have managed to get an ambiance style theme to work after installing gnome-tweak-tool from the repos. I'm not keen on the default gnome 3 desktop theme at all. It is nice to be customising themes again something not particularly possible yet in Unity. The desktop looks quite slick and I like the Activies animation, dropdown menus & notifications from Gwibber. Having to hold the Alt key to select power-off is a pain, its turned a one-hand action into a two hand action, maybe thats the point but I just don't get it. Moving from window to window or desktop to desktop is snappy and it feels very responsive. However it's a shame you have to mouse over top left to reveal different desktops and then select a desktop from the desktop switcher that is on the far right of the screen it just seems like the cursor is doing more screen-miles than necessary. In Unity the desktop switcher is on the launcher and that feels like a better arrangement to me. Also, I don't like having to mouse over top-left of the screen to reveal open windows and bring up the dock I prefer the mouse over edge of screen approach, that Unity seems to have adopted, it feels like a more natural way to reveal a 'dock'.
Day 2 I'm getting used to the interface. Whilst I'm perhaps not totally up to speed I'm finding it more familiar. I discovered the Wikipedia and Google search buttons at the bottom of the Activities search results, hopefully its possible to customise these or add others. Nice idea though! I have also started using the <super> key to bring up the Activities menu screen rather than mousing to the top left of the screen. I have also found an extension that can move the hot-corner to the right hand side. Third party extensions are however liable to breakages when gnome-shell changes, so I'll try and avoid them for now. one nice discovery was that gnome-shell uses
CSS theming so there's a real chance for me to get tinkering with theme alterations, etc.
Day 3I have this instance of Ubuntu installed on my netbook and the gnome 3 desktop works well on a small screen and with the big icons I can see it lending itself well to a touchscreen/tablet PC. Today is also the release day of Ubuntu 11.10 and I resisted booting into Unity to see if there had been any last changes. Oh! yeah, I need to find the quickest way to the Rubbish Bin - I must be missing something here?
Day 4Although I have been impressed with the speed of the gnome 3 desktop and since I started using it I have found no bugs. I think Unity is the better looking.
Day 5I have been using my netbook out and about today.One thing I have noticed is the power consumption of Ubuntu 11.10 is not improved noticably by running the gnome 3 desktop instead of Unity. However, I am starting to think the battery in my netbook which has been used constantly for 18 months or more is as much to blame for decrease in battery-life as Ubuntu.
Day 6Today I have realised I am missing the Unity menu bar integration. The screen real-estate saved on a 10" is appreciated.
Day 7Last day of gnome 3 desktop diary. Gnome 3 offers a perfectly usable alternative to the default Ubuntu 11.10 Unity desktop. Its fast, seemingly stable and has many nice features. Whether I prefer it to Unity or not I'm not sure. I think in my case Unity probably comes out a little ahead. I'll let you know when I boot back into Unity. But I know one thing. I'm not one of those people who will constantly lament the demise of the classic Gnome 2 desktop.