Friday, 4. March 2005, 04:36:36
Two rendering engines should make this browser worth looking at.
It's got a stylish theme which looks very plastic and candy wrapped, and certainly looks impressive. However, to use the interface, it's hard. They've made some basic mistakes - Icons for functions I'm not used to which are meaningless. For instance, there's a person's head and "01010" underneath it. Apparently, this is a "passcard". It doesn't look like a photo ID in the slightest - I don't associate it with an identity manager at all.
Another annoyance that blares out at me: pages that finish loading are brought into focus. I don't realise new windows are spawned (ok, that's pretty slick), but it's a disadvantage to me as it fails to act like a normal windows application - I get lost in finding my way about.
Another oddity - the reason every windows application has the toolbars in the same place is because the user is used to them - located on the right and too close to the close/minimize/maximize buttons for comfort we find Netscape's menu. The "RSS" button obscures the URL, which is unfortunate, and most of the rest of the UI looks a bit blockish - looking at my own XUL aint pretty, I can tell you that.
On :hover's with toolbar buttons has a bug that needs addressing, the images to the left & right aren't dealt with very well.
The "1 2 3 4 5" buttons in my linkbar area aren't descriptive of their function in the slightest. The lower status bar is extremely underutilised - firefox demonstrated to me that it could have a function purpose as a container, but netscape has ignored that, instead opting for high clutter in the upper area.
Aside from these behavioural differences, it's a Fox in Sheep's clothing. The IE engine can be invoked in the stupidest situations (Do you want to render this page with IE? No, you stupid browser, it's XUL, disable this!).
I don't think Firefox's marketshare is threatened by this browser. I think Opera will be safe too. It will drag some away from the Big Blue E and that's a good thing - but it won't be many people.
Also, this has the added benefits of outside eyes looking at Mozilla code, thus increasing the chance of bugs being found and fixed.
I think most of the issues with plugins stem from the RDF manifest stating "I work in firefox X to XX" and Netscape IDs as something different.
Another good feature: Big, blaring box of "Internet Explorer is rubbish" when switching the rendering engine... hurrah.
It's
available for Download.