If I don't want to visit Milton Keynes, you can't make me.
Monday, 1. June 2009, 00:45:11
I don't want to get caught up in the digital rights thing right now, but I am fascinated by the case against the entertainments industry's call for a ban on habitual copyright offenders, for quite a different reason. The defence goes like this:- “Disconnecting consumers from the internet is head-in-the-sand protectionism, and reflects the entertainment industries' failure to adapt to the emerging digital world,” said Consumer Focus’s deputy chief executive Philip Cullum. “The industry must stop wasting time promoting old fashioned protectionist policies and start finding new ways of delivering digital content.”
My question is simple. Why? If the copyright owners don't want their content to be used in some specific way then they have the right not to do it. Just because I have a bicycle that doesn't mean I have to cycle every road and track in the UK simply because I can, and just because I have a guitar that doesn't give anyone the right to video me and stick it on Youtube.
When exactly did organisations like Consumer Focus take ownership of the internet? It's not theirs and they have no right to insist that everyone should use it the way they want it used. If someone makes a movie and decides for reasons known only to him or herself that they don't want it circulated on the 'net then that's their right. They own the thing so it's their right to do what they like with it, and that means that it's also their right not to do what they don't want to do with it.
Everyone seems to want to use the internet to get what they can out of it for themselves. Me, I just want to wander around it and maybe connect with other people while I'm here, or maybe just enjoy what's there because it's there, which is pretty much the same reason why I ride a bike and play the guitar.
My question is simple. Why? If the copyright owners don't want their content to be used in some specific way then they have the right not to do it. Just because I have a bicycle that doesn't mean I have to cycle every road and track in the UK simply because I can, and just because I have a guitar that doesn't give anyone the right to video me and stick it on Youtube.
When exactly did organisations like Consumer Focus take ownership of the internet? It's not theirs and they have no right to insist that everyone should use it the way they want it used. If someone makes a movie and decides for reasons known only to him or herself that they don't want it circulated on the 'net then that's their right. They own the thing so it's their right to do what they like with it, and that means that it's also their right not to do what they don't want to do with it.
Everyone seems to want to use the internet to get what they can out of it for themselves. Me, I just want to wander around it and maybe connect with other people while I'm here, or maybe just enjoy what's there because it's there, which is pretty much the same reason why I ride a bike and play the guitar.














