Skip navigation.

You Can't Lose What You Never Had

Once upon a time, I had an internet boyfriend. It’s juvenile, and embarrassing to admit, but it’s true. I was introduced to him several years ago via his Opera blog, and I was instantly captivated by his insightful writing, his (apparently) staggering intelligence. My first correspondence with him made me nervous. Surely, I thought, this man is going to think I’m an imbecile. I agonized over the choice of my words, trying to construct sentences that that were cool yet friendly, articulate but not showy. To my surprise, he didn’t ignore me or mock me. I was encouraged. The frequency of our correspondence increased, as did the depth of the subjects about which we would correspond. The emails led to phone calls, and over the course of a year or more, I began to suspect that I was in love with this person.

The human mind is a powerful tool. It can shape reality like one of those guys that carves statues out of ice with a chainsaw. In this life, most people see only what they want to see; instead of frozen water, we see a dripping, glistening angel. This is even easier to do when you never actually have to see the truth that is tucked away in another time zone half a world away. Its easy to have a relationship with a guy whose farts you never have to smell, whose ex-girlfriend’s photograph isn’t haunting the sock drawer. It’s very easy when the person is just a photograph themselves, or a disembodied voice saying nice things to you over thousands of miles of telephone wire. Unless, of course you think you're in love, in which case you want to snuggle with them and eat waffles in your underpants.

Naturally, meeting one another face-to-face was the next step. I hadn’t told him I loved him, of course, nor he I. But because I had been carrying around the secret knowledge of my love like a burning jewel in my chest, I was eager to tip the hand of fate. It didn’t matter that he lived thousands of miles away and the entire situation was wildly impractical. I am a hopeless romantic. Love, I was sure, was about overcoming the obstacles and proving everyone wrong. I was dazzled by the potential of “our story” and determined to go to him against the advice of everyone I knew. I would be like a shot of distilled sunshine. Once he’d swallowed me, I would radiate warmth throughout his guts. I would soften the cruel edges of his reality and whisk away the gloom. And when at last he saw that his world had become a soft place, he would fall.

So I went. I flung myself into someone’s arms and plead my case. But the man in whose arms I slept was not the man I loved. In fact, that man did not exist, and never had. He was an animated construct in my mind, a flimsy scaffolding of ideas over which a tapestry of words had been stretched. I danced him all around my imagination, dreaming about his exceptionally fine company, his sparkling dinner conversation, his brilliant massages. And when I gazed into his eyes over a bouquet of flowers (which he’d picked for me), I would see rolling prairies filled with love, undulating and endless, and all for me. I was so enamored with my vision that it obscured the reality, the way a mirage cloaks the brownness of the desert floor.

Some months later, at my impetuous urgings, he abandoned his life to move and be with me. He showed up one morning unexpected, bleary-eyed and lugging two shabby suitcases. I’ll never know why he did it. Maybe he thought he had to. Maybe he was just lonely, or maybe he, like me, was chasing a person made of words and dreams, a girl who wasn’t me. In any case, the excuse he offered was that he loved me. That he was on my doorstep was all the proof I needed. But you can’t prove something that isn’t true, no matter how hard you try.

In less than two months the ice sculpture had melted, and I had trouble reconciling the man I loved with the formless dampness that shared my bed. I kept looking and looking for those love-prairie eyes, and all I saw were toadstools. I didn’t know what had happened, where my brilliant, special boyfriend had gone. It was like a missing persons case. Day after day went by until I just had to accept that I would never hold the man I loved. It was a truth as hard and final as death. I mourned my poor, dead boyfriend, and raged against the imposter who didn’t know how I took my coffee, and couldn’t make me smile.

When he finally left, I wanted to hate him. But he was only a sad stranger in an old overcoat, just like he’d always been. For a while I was angry at myself instead, embarrassed at my foolishness, my pride wounded at the idea that I wasn’t clever or pretty or enlightened enough to have brought the puppet in my mind to life. He had come all that way, but he still didn’t love me. It’s me, I thought. I’m the creeping fungus that devoured the love-prairie and put out the light in his eyes.

Why am I telling you all of this? I don’t know honestly. Maybe because I know that there are other hopeless romantics out there that might be on the cusp of making the same mistake. And maybe some of them read my blog. I know what you’re thinking- that the really important lessons in life have to be learned the hard way, even though they usually seem obvious. But, for what it’s worth, you can’t love a person you’ve never met. It defies the very principle of the word. To quote a song by some gospel singer whose cassette tape my mom used to play in the car: Love is not a feeling, it’s an act of your will.

Five Things You Probably Didn't Know About Me If You Only Know Me From My Blog

Comments

wickedlizard 29. December 2006, 11:57

oh god! been there.... :ko:

musickna 29. December 2006, 14:14

Also been there - way back in the days when chatrooms and not blogs were the fad. It was a disaster through and through, and had I not been in a deep bout of untreated depression, it would never have happened. But the fantasy and delusion you write about - yes, I know those all too well. :frown:

Yours is a beautifully written story - glad you came out the other side wiser as well as disillusioned. :smile:

Esme_11 29. December 2006, 16:47

Thanks for reading, guys. It's nice to know I'm not the only fool out there. Interesting that you mention the deep depression, musickna, because the man I speak of, the real guy, was PROFOUNDLY depressed. I think I was a little bit too. It had been our common bond. But it's a terrible, destructive bond to share.

wickedlizard 29. December 2006, 18:27

I too, was depressed back then and the guy too was profoundly so...

angel292005 29. December 2006, 22:08

that was beautiful, thanks for sharing.

Capegirl 30. December 2006, 00:44

tsk tsk. silly fools all of us. i've never met a knight in shining armor. i love myself far more than any man. i truly appreciate the heartspace this came from, however. i'm not supposed to be here. this may be a recording. winkety, wink, wink!

Esme_11 30. December 2006, 06:05

Oh, I don't think knights in shining armor exist anymore, if they ever did. I think they were invented just so dragons would have someone to play with while folded up together in the storybooks. I'm glad to hear you say you love yourself more than any man- that's admirable. Makes me a little jealous, really. I can't say that I truly love myself, though I know I should. I don't mean that to say I hate myself either, and I certainly get my panties in a wad if someone is hateful to me. But do I love myself? I don't know what that means, really. It's something I want to learn. I think it's important. There's a very short list of things I've really figured out in life. I hope I live to be a hundred - I'm a slow learner.

Capegirl 30. December 2006, 15:28

i'm aiming for 130, myself!

my body's marked with roadmaps of errant journeys taken, i assure you. my romanticism is the stuff of legend!. I've loved longer and harder than even i thought possible. i just have learned the hard way what love means to me. or i've made a choice about what that is going to mean. i've framed it differently. for one thing love doesn't hurt. for another it's hard work and not a dream.

plenty of folks out there will take my penchant for loving and use it to serve their own sad places. i've learned to raise my hand and say "stop" setting boundaries is not easy for me. and i'm often a bit late on the uptake, but i do it now. for my own protection.

loving myself. i know it sounds glib. it's not a lightning bolt of clarity either. it's a skill, i've found that needs to be practiced.daily. for me its about doing what is to my benefit and to the benefit of others. as one would for an infant, or a puppy or a goldfish. a balance between freedom and accountablity is working for me.

i've plenty of wadded up panties in my closet. now i wear boy leg panties. they don't creep up the ass quite so much. :D

wickedlizard 30. December 2006, 15:37

:lol: :D

Esme_11 30. December 2006, 18:36

HA HA HA! That's funny.

What you say about doing what is to your benefit and nourishing yourself like an infant is profound to me. And helpful. I'm always all too ready to sell myself out for someone else just so that they'll love me or like me or include me or whatever. Then I feel pathetic and resentful because I've allowed someone else to take over my life. It's happened in friendships and romantic relationships more times than I can remember. It's so destructive and sad, and I usually wind up hurting people who love me because all the resentment I feel makes me think they don't really love me after all. I've started attending a support group for co-dependent women. I never knew what that word meant before, but I think I am. Anyway, maybe that's the first step to loving myself.

I too have had to re-evalute and re-frame my concept of the word love, but I'm not done yet, I don't think. What you said about love not hurting seems entirely foreign to me. For ages now I've thought of love like a sickness, a kind of emotional flu. Like a fever, it cooks your brain and makes you crazy. It fills your middle parts up with a weird kind of ache that only half a bottle of whiskey can dull. To treat it is costly, and it is sometimes incurable and leaves your heart criss-crossed with tough scar tissue that limits its movements when it's healed.

You know, I told the guy I wrote about in this post, the guy from the internet, that he couldn't love anyone else unless he loved himself first. I was very high-and-mighty in the face of his self-loathing. But it turns out I'm just a hypocrite with a plank in my eye.

Capegirl 30. December 2006, 23:14

hmm.. lets see. i think we all do that high and mighty bit at times. mostly when we've been wounded. just this week i had a mild to moderate hissy fit about something that didn't turn out too well. it ended when i stopped asking "how dare he?" and started asking "how dare i?" by which i mean what did I do that led to the pain I was feeling? then it was less a case of "how did this happen" and more a case of "how could it not?"

the hypocrisy you mentioned...i think we teach what we most need to learn. for me i've chosen to see that as a good thing. for example parents do this all the time..when they teach their kids to eat right or cross the street properly or not trust strangers even though they themselves are not getting these things right. it comes from wanting the best for another. it's also how a healing cycle works..i help you, you help another and so on...often it's when we're trying to help somebody else that out own penny drops. i love that.

the best way i learned to love was from the experience of somebody loving me. he didn't give me what i wanted! but he WAS loving me.

the scenario you describe in the first bit of your last comment. i've done that tons of times and the tendency is still there, i promise ya! it's a bit like having flabby tummy muscles, self love is. you can either sit there lamenting the whole thing or get on the floor and do some crunches. i personally hate crunches and i sometimes despise doing the self-love bit. self sabotage feels so much more natural! but i reckon i like a strong abdominal core more and a strong emotional core even better.

love (or more correctly) lust does make us crazy. but i figure our experience of love is largely based on how we view it. so to give ourselves a chance we maybe need to think it's ultimately a good thing. not lust though, lust is some seriously bad BLOW!

hey Emily there's people who've done worse shit than you and i. we're ok girl. :D

Capegirl 30. December 2006, 23:34

on a lighter note it helps me tons to keep a sense of humor about this stuff. it stops me from throwing wadded up tissues at the TV. so when i feel my nose is all out of joint i say:

"step away from the HIGH HORSE. Place your hands on the animal's flanks. DO NOT make any sudden movements!"

that, and "stuffs getting better all the time"

:D

Wakajawaka 1. January 2007, 20:44

That was a QUALITY piece of writing!!

lokutus_prime 4. January 2007, 11:10

re "That was a QUALITY piece of writing!!"

Concise and totally accurate ... but then, E. is a QUALITY writer and she attracts such responses to what ever she writes.

lokutus_prime 4. January 2007, 11:14

A very Happy New Year to you, dear E.

Lo

Esme_11 5. January 2007, 00:46

Thanks, guys! These compliments are like a couple of maraschino cherries on top of a friggin' awesome day! I love all of you so much I wish I could squirt whipped cream into your dear little mouths!

vaspers88 13. January 2007, 07:47

You have a lovely blog and the confessions of a life of upside downs seems to almost comb the hair of the dawn. We surcharge the halo lol.

whybother 5. February 2007, 18:36

This entry was quite compelling. I'm not new to your blog, but after reading this I will be visiting it more often. I didn't know what to expect from this story of love gone stale, but you seem not to know what expect either, judging from your comments to other readers. It's nice to know there are others who don't have a clue. Sometimes I start to wonder if I'm the only one. Good job, nice work, thanks for making me feel a little less lame.

mydistantlover 7. February 2007, 05:38

I disagree with the concept that you can't love someone you've never met. However I agree that it is crazy and the person probably needs help. However, it is better to have loved and lost, as they say. My story is similiar however we became best friends first. True pen pals sharing our lives on a computer screen. Eight years went by and the friendship continued to grow and with that an increase in the intimacy of the conversation, however always as friends, not lovers. Then last year I fell in love. Our conversations were more frequent, his words became more meaningful, and although we were oceans apart, I looked up one day and I was in love. A love that was one-sided, that could possibly destroy a friendship, and that so passionate I became ill and found it difficult to sleep or eat. I never could tell him, (although I joked about it on occasion) for fear of loosing a long-time friend. Despite how crazy it sounds or how emtionally ill the person might be, loving someone for all the wrong reasons can be just as rewarding as loving for all the right reasons. He will never know how much I love him, and we will probably never meet, but its okay. Hopefully one day the love will fade and the pain of loving someone I've never met will go away. Until then I read the works (poetry) of James Whitcomb Riley. He loved and wrote love letters to his "Lizzie from 1879-1884. They never met either - and eventually his love for her faded. But hay! loving someone feels damn good.

Säm 14. March 2007, 18:26

Wow, what an odd experience, kind of makes me cringe, how terrible.

I_ArtMan 19. March 2007, 01:08

this comment pile has been of enormous interest as well as increased respect for you for speaking so frankly and remaining avowedly open to further investigation.

you and i haven't been active operateers recently... it comes and goes with me.

wickedlizard 6. April 2007, 00:15

emily where did you go???

rssy 15. April 2007, 03:30

thanks that you wrote the story about yourself and tell us we can’t love a person we’ve never met.
It's true and forever.
'cause you will live in your imaginations all the time !

It's happy to meet you on the net, you're so bright! :smile:

lesoldatperdu 17. April 2007, 18:25

I hope you're still writing, Emily.

angel292005 11. January 2008, 20:10

Happy New Year 2008 Emily, if you ever check this. Wish you would come back.

Sarah

Write a comment

You must be logged in to write a comment. If you're not a registered member, please sign up.

December 2009
S M T W T F S
November 2009January 2010
1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31