The God Complex
Saturday, October 8, 2011 4:06:28 PM
How easily we forget the past. This video from April this year is a look at the failings Apple has made in the corporate world, from the suicides of workers under outrageous conditions to Steve Jobs shutting down the philanthropy section of the business in 1997 (part of his much lauded but rarely detailed plan to save the company) and keeping it so tightly shut that iTunes bans applications that can make direct donations to charities.
So many of the retrospectives I've read over the past few days have talked only about what this man brought to the world, ignoring some of the dubious steps he took to do so. The man was far from a saint yet, before his corpse had even cooled, the world decided to deify him once they found out he was dead. In a rather extreme but no less valid example, it's like congratulating Hitler on the advances to genetic research and medicine that were a result of the freedom he gave his doctors in the concentration camps. Perhaps a more recent example would be talking about the way Bin Laden highlighted the need for extra airport security. These are extremes of course, but show how ridiculous it is for us to focus only on the good things in a person's life when they die as a way of showing respect for them. Surely marking their accomplishments while noticing their failings is the more honest tribute?Even more damning is that many of the accomplishments being lauded on him by these articles aren't even true. I'm not talking about the advances that have been attributed to him but that must have come from other staff at Apple, by the way, but about the things people are now claiming he invented that are simply not true. The first testimonial I read declared that the iPhone was the first phone capable of browsing the web or sending e-mail, another has claimed that the iPod was the first ever touchscreen device in the world, and a third talked about additions coming to iOS this year that have been copied from other platforms but got it mixed up so that it seemed the other platforms were copying iOS. None of these things are accomplishments of this man and their inclusion cheapens what he actually did do in his life, just as much as hiding the cost of the advances he made cheapens them, both showing how little time the media has to actually bother researching the stories they put forward about him. Deifying him in this way is not honouring his memory, but allowing yourself to be fooled into forgetting the truth.
And the truth is that this was just a man with good qualities and flaws, a man who left work in order to finally be able to spend time with his family and who had a tragically short time to spend with them.

MConor # Saturday, October 8, 2011 4:40:42 PM
Dark FurieFurie # Saturday, October 8, 2011 4:46:25 PM
Gavin Tripp-Sheedygarlingmatthews # Saturday, October 8, 2011 4:53:27 PM
You don't get to be a C.E.O. for a multi-billion dollar company by being a saint.
MConor # Saturday, October 8, 2011 4:57:03 PM
KittyliciousZaphira # Saturday, October 8, 2011 7:17:37 PM
Dark FurieFurie # Saturday, October 8, 2011 8:14:13 PM
Originally posted by garlingmatthews:
Unfortunately it's the Apple fans who are redistributing the point to other levels by saying outlandish things about the devices' capabilities. This is all while Apple themselves are claiming things about them that aren't true and attacking others for being better specified than them. Had the iPhone been released as the underpowered internet phone that Jobs first showed to the world, I'd have nothing to say about it rather than to applaud the idea but say it was too early and that they needed more than second generation mobile capabilities to make it work well in Europe. The constant false advertising and law breaking that they've gone through to make it as deified as he is becoming is what pissed me off. It may well just work, but it doesn't do what Apple have implied it does and what half the Apple fans say it can.Originally posted by garlingmatthews:
Exactly, so people should stop making out he is one. On the other hand you've got members of the Westboro Baptist Church (remember them?) saying publicly that he is burning in hell now for not giving God enough glory and teaching sin. Neither is true as humans are a mix of the good and the bad.On the subject of the Westboro Loonies, I wonder if they get the irony of this or if they'll say God has purified them enough to not fall under the evil of the device... http://media.share.ovi.com/m1/s/3161/f34e15bbd522432c95682231dce6b13b.jpg -

Originally posted by MConor:
The difference is mainly in the options available to the user compared to the way things are presented to the user. You can do less with the device you're using, but what you can do is presented in a much prettier way. One example would be screen transitions. Turn a regular phone from 2005 (first accelerometer) even up to modern day, and you'll see the screen go blank for a millisecond then load the screen in landscape rather than portrait. An Apple device would use the graphics processor and animate the transition. It's a subtle effect but one of quite a few that fans swear by and that make a difference to their lives. For a power user like myself, such things are a distraction that doesn't quite cover the fact that I'm missing features I've been used to having, but I can appreciate how these things matter to people who have lesser needs and want to see their money working.Originally posted by Zaphira:
Ah, go on then. I'll let you add it.MConor # Saturday, October 8, 2011 8:25:56 PM
Point is, all Jobs was was a man. But he had a profound effect on a lot of things, and that shouldn't be ignored. In the end, all he was was a man. But it's his effect on people that will be remembered. For better or worse, he changed the world, and he certainly changed me.
Gavin Tripp-Sheedygarlingmatthews # Saturday, October 8, 2011 8:26:21 PM
It's true that Apple stuff rarely does anything new. The difference is that it does it in a way that the 97% of the world who aren't nerds can get a handle on. I never have to show people how their iPhones work.
That said, can I move images from my Nokia to my iPad via bluetooth? Nothing human is frustration free.
Dark FurieFurie # Saturday, October 8, 2011 9:06:53 PM
Originally posted by garlingmatthews:
And yet they bring out thousands of magazines showing people how to use their iPhones. You never get that with Windows.Originally posted by garlingmatthews:
Nokia sometimes has a problem staying connected to non-Nokia via Bluetooth. It may be worth checking to see if that's the problem.Originally posted by MConor:
And with a few hundred extra features... They may not be the most important in the world but they're what the hardcore like myself need in a mobile device.Metro UI is nice to the point that I'm training my Android devices to look that way. I already have apps organised into hubs as that is the way my own design for a smartphone OS goes, and each of these hubs is accessed from a tile on the rear of the homescreen, which flips with a swipe. Took three applications working in tandem just to get that effect.
Originally posted by MConor:
Show us on the doll where he changed you.MConor # Saturday, October 8, 2011 9:13:53 PM
Gavin Tripp-Sheedygarlingmatthews # Saturday, October 8, 2011 9:52:27 PM
Mad Scientistqlue # Sunday, October 9, 2011 2:36:14 PM
I've downgraded to a basic window manager which gives me greater flexibility and user less resources. It's not suitable for everyone, but it fits my needs better than fancy visual effects and lot's of default apps that I don't use anyway.
And I'm still using my Nokia E65 with firmware from 2004.
Pineas2 # Monday, October 10, 2011 7:59:34 AM
Gavin Tripp-Sheedygarlingmatthews # Monday, October 10, 2011 5:26:02 PM
Tagent.
Darkogdare # Tuesday, October 11, 2011 6:29:34 AM