Ally McBeal - seasons 3-5
Friday, 6. November 2009, 17:24:14
- John CageThe world is no longer a romantic place. Some of its people still are however, and therein lies the promise. Don't let the world win, Ally McBeal.
Before the summer, I reviewed the first two seasons of Ally McBeal, and then took a break from the show. When I returned to it this autumn, however, I found that I'd missed it more than I realised. Something about this show just gets to me on an emotional level.
The acting is good - much of it downright great - and the heavy use of music is both engaging and obvious without feeling intrusive. As people who know me well will attest, I'm a sucker for a good musical, and a horde of episodes of this show are closet-musicals dying to be let out. The season three finale is even named Ally McBeal: The musical, Almost.
I'm sure this point alone threw a lot of you off, but don't worry, with the exception of that episode, people don't really burst into song here. There's the odd exception, sure, but for the most part, what they burst into is dancing. And good gods, I love their dancing. There is something so beautiful to this group of tight-knit friends who'll spontaneously start dancing to the song existing only in their minds. I'm not ashamed - though perhaps slightly embarrassed - to admit that many of these little dancing-scenes moved me to tears just from the sheer joy expressed on screen. There's something special about that.
The quote I opened with definitely describes the main character, but it also goes for the show - perhaps even more so. Those who've seen Kelley's Boston Legal knows he's an ace at combining the ridiculously silly with the heart-warmingly poignant and beautiful, and Ally McBeal is just as good at it. But where Boston Legal is a soap box for grand political statements, McBeal combines its warmth with personal stories. The little everyday neurosis, the tiny social dramas blown out of proportions, the soap without the box, if you would.
With all this emotion, it is perhaps no surprise the show is frequently hysterically funny - and frequently also rather sad. Reality is a constant threat hovering around the walls of the offices of Cage & Fish, and sometimes, even this crazy group of rich lawyers have to deal with tragedies pushed on them from the outside. Sometimes reality even catches up with them internally, and those are perhaps the saddest scenes of all.
While most characters on this show leave a mark, some must be mentioned by name. Flockhart's McBeal is an obvious start - the show is very much about her. You basically have to go watch House to find a show more clearly centered on its protagonist. And yet, as the show progresses, we get entire episodes were she basically doesn't even appear, symptomatic of what this really is - an ensemble show in disguise. I mentioned McBeal rather thoroughly in my previous post, however, and I also covered my other favourites - the characters of Ling, Nelle and more than anyone else the incredibly awesome John Cage and Richard Fish. I'll thus skip over them and mention some other characters that also left a mark.
Most missed, perhaps, of those who remain, is Robert Downey Jr.'s Larry Paul of season 4. [SKIP TO THE NEXT PARAGRAPH IF YOU'VE NEVER SEEN SEASON 4 OR 5] His departure from the show is still hurting both Ally and the viewer a full season later - that's a product of good writing, absolutely, but it also says something about how incredibly strong Downey Jr's performance was. Heck, I still walk around wishing there was just one more episode for him to potentially come back in, and the show's been over since 2002.
Also, Elaine Vassal. Frequently annoying, even more frequently amusing, and always, always sympathetic, she's the character I realise I most frequently under-appreciate when I talk about this show. She provides a grounding in reality and a broad highway straight into crazy at the same time, and in both cases, it is a much more simple, straightforward - in my eyes, admirable - view of life than the title character ever manages. Good going, Jane Krakowski.
Finally - ruthlessly skipping over all those who also deserve mention - Hayden Panettiere's appearance in the final season as a ten year old. Where did she throw these acting skills away before she started starring on Heroes? Someone should find them for her. Anyway, I rarely find child actors to be more than passable at best, and usually they're downright annoying. Not here. I wouldn't say I loved the character, but it was a character it would have been very easy to hate, and I didn't at all.
As usual, I've ended up talking mostly about characters - I guess it's clear what I care about in a show. But plots are hardly irrelevant. Without spoiling anything, what I said initially about reality is very much the case in all of these three seasons. Simplified, season three deals with reality's increasing grip on the internal mechanisms of the group. Season four looks at reality's hold on Ally herself, and both her and other central characters' personal lives, especially romantically. Season five finishes off with the final pounding of the barbarians of the real on the gates of Cage & Fish, and the eventual, unavoidable outcome.
Some of the classical weaknesses of Kelley's shows, such as the tendency to completely shift around the casts with little to no explanations between seasons, only really occurs between season 4 and 5, and even there, most of it is pretty minor and easily explained. The show is smart, it's funny, it's engaging, and it's going to stand proudly at the front of my DVD-shelf - alphabetical ordering really speaks in Ally's favour. Most importantly, this show, for all its crazy fantasies, obsessive characters, self-centred drama and soapy plot-points, this show is human. So very human. Maybe not like most human experience actually is, but by Jove, the way it should be.
With a song in your heart every single day; and a spontaneous group-dance in the unisex.
Looking backwards, many of the saddest times in my life turn out to be the happiest.
So I must be happy now. Yeah. This is gonna be good.
Why else would I be crying?












