And the winner is...
Tuesday, 6. May 2008, 11:23:07
I've been trying the main 3 free antivirus, AVG, AVAST and ANTIVIR. Now, AVG version 8 doesn't even install correctly on Win2K (scheduler and updater are disabled), ANTIVIR sucks a lot of resources, takes forever to open dialogs and gives me a BSOD from time to time (probably only when it finds some other software running, do not know which), AVAST is the most complicated antivirus ever, with several resident modules for monitoring different activities, a skinnable GUI, options distributed in "hard to find" dialogs here and here. On top AVAST misses heuristics besides the mail module.
At the end, given the catastrofic failures of AVG and ANTIVIR I am using AVAST, with the bare minimum of modules installed but thinking of living without any "on access" scanner and use CLAMAV (ported to Win) from time to time.
Edit: did I say AVAST? So far I got this interesting "features":
1. scanning my 170MB Thunderbird mailbox it generates 2 or 3 120MB temp files, if I stop the scanning before it ends those temp files are left on the disk in the _avast_ directory. It seems also that after creating those files AVAST doesn't actually do anything, skipping the content. On a side note, ClamAV does the same with temporary files if you "cancel" before completion.
2. there is a feature to block (it asks for authorisation) writing of executable files, unfortunately it is triggered also by directories whose name is "mario.com" and some software installers create such folders, for example TopStyle. An alert is risen any time you access a dir if some subdir has such names.
3. automatic updates of the virus signatures can cripple the scanning engine.