photo of Marjan Krebelj

profound thoughts

Deconstructivism

, , ,

This post is my little contribution on understanding contemporary art, especially architecture and design. It is not written for architects and designers (they are supposed to already know that), but for normal people who want to know something more about what's going on now in architecture and understand it. So I have to warn experts and "experts" that some simplifications are neccecary, but basicly the point is there.

Click below to continue...

To understand the whole thing, we have to look back in time. The whole Euro-Atlantic history of architecture is based on it's roots in Ancient Greek architecture, more or less, on it's temple. The most profound example of that is Parthenon (Athens). Some periods were more about that (like renaissance) some less (like gothic architecture). But untill late 19th century we have quite steady flow of all those columns, pillars (etc) eventhough the variations in ideas are quite significant and sometimes with high level of contradiction (like renaissance vs. baroque).

But in early 20th century steel and concrete were introduced to construction. Young and abmitious architects soon became aware of it's potential and began to create compleetly new forms. Some of them also thaught that classic ornament is totally out and clean geometric forms are the right thing to pursue. If you mix that together with uprising socialist ideas of that time (between WW I. and WW II.) you get modernistic architecture with its founder Le Corbusier. Their style is today called modernism. At the begining they were considered quite rebelious, but then again, every revolutionary movement was based on the idea that old garde should simply fuck off [Freud would say it is just a symbol for son vs. father]. On the left is famous Villa Savoye which is more like a statement or manifest than a house.

Well they didn't last long... In late 70's people soon realised that Le Courbusier's ideas contain to many simplifications. Many of them come from socialistic way of thinking which denies human as an indivitual beeing with individual needs and also individuality as a need it self. Most of the pionir modernists were already very old or even dead that time, so the new generation wanted them to "fuck off", but they didn't exactly have a plan how to do it. So they figure it out, that they should return to classic aestethic, based on Greek temple. This new movement was later on called postmodernism and is particulary significant in USA where many houses were built exactly like they were 2000 years old. Some went a bit further and used new materials, but basicly they didn't invent anything new.
Postmodern houses can be easily recognised; they were built between 1970-1990, they are usually very symetric, they use columns and pillars, arches (especially at the enerance) and other "modernised" elements of classic ancient building. The problem is, that most of those architects don't really know a lot about ancient architecture and they are just blindly repeating (and some of them are not very good at that either). On the left you have Humana Building (Louisville) by Michael Graves, which is rather good architecture, but next example is IMHO grotesque: Piazza D´Italia, New Orleans:



°~°

So soon they realised, that this is not the path to go. We can't built Greek temples for ever... If we send man on the moon, read DNA, drive cars, use internet (etc) we have to make similar step forwart in architecture and design as well.

Two directions were formed. First is minimalism, which is theoreticly based upon Mies van der Rohe's quote "less is more". That is somehow correct, but rare are those who master design so well, that can achieve high level of expression and aesthetics with such minimum. Not everyone is Mies.


The other direction is much more interesting to me. It is called deconstructivism and was founded by Bernard Tschumi. They deny completly everything... Even the orthogonal geometry that was so obvious for the whole history now breakes down and is completly irrelavant (see the picture below). Every "roule" falls under doubt and suspicion. The term de-construct-ivism describes what happens in someones head; the basic idea of an object (like house, for example) is smashed [=deconstructed] into smallest possible pieces, each of them is carefully thaught over and then re-constructed back with new logic. A deconstrictivistic arist will ask himself; is this neccecary or can it be done differently. If it can, then how?



The first deconstructivistc poject was made by Bernard Tschumi as entry for Parc de la Villette contest. After that many followed. One that is considered to be very important was The Jewish Museum in Berlin by Daniel Libeskind (pictured on the left).

Deconstructivism searches it's theoretical background in achievements of modern day science, such as psyhology, biology, mechanichal engeneering etc... They tend to use high-tech materials that enable them new forms and shapes.

So here we are today with many great architects and designers trying to redefine our way of thinking. Many of those projects are experimental, but they might lead to new ways of designing, housing and even living. A house for today's living must include all paradigms and paradigm shifts we are facing today, incliding electronic comunications, high level of individualism and rapid social and environmental changes. Constant rethinking of every possible idea might be a right answer to that.
On the bottom: Mediterranean Museum of Nuragic and Contemporary Art by Zaha Hadid



New headphonesThrill

Comments

Djordje Gavrilovicdjoshlosh Thursday, May 24, 2007 9:46:56 AM

Vrlo lepo si ovo napisao

SofiaBeann Thursday, May 24, 2007 10:50:20 AM

Extremly beautiful. The last one.
Unfortunately, modern architecture moves on street not so fast as it would like to...

yooperprof Friday, July 20, 2007 2:48:16 AM

Oooh, I like Zaha Hadid's Mediterranean Museum. Where is it/will it be?

GulfGirl Sunday, November 18, 2007 10:31:30 PM

Interesting comments and photos. For a look at a different way to create classic architecture have a loook at this modular concrete system , http://www.ConcreteCottage.com
Several people are trying itin different parts of the States, California, Louisiana, Florida, Alabama.

Marjan KrebeljNikio Sunday, November 18, 2007 10:57:51 PM

GulfGirl: that's exactly what I'm trying to discourage. You can apply modular system in a new fashion, without reproducing old and outdated designs.

Unregistered user Saturday, May 2, 2009 8:12:29 AM

Anonymous writes: weee

Unregistered user Saturday, July 18, 2009 5:49:47 PM

Chen writes: If you like deconstructivism, why don't you like Piaza D'Italia? Myself I don't like deconstructivism; they are turning into a fashion product. I believe that the future of archicture is one that focusing on helping the environment, as well as helping society, instead of simple eye-candy. Atleast that is my hope.

Unregistered user Monday, August 31, 2009 2:57:51 PM

Anonymous writes: Why is she (Zaha hadid) following the concept of deconstructivism? Is it just an experimentation or does it have a logic behind it....? And the major one, " what is the diffrence between The old styles and the Deconstructivism?"

Marjan KrebeljNikio Monday, August 31, 2009 6:59:14 PM

As for Zaha, you should ask her... I don't know.
The difference between the old styles and deconstructivism would be, that deconstructivism doesnt use 90 degrees angle anymore. Almost anything is allowed as long as it doesn't follow traditional geometry.

Unregistered user Wednesday, September 2, 2009 9:14:00 AM

Anonymous writes: @ Nikio Then tell me one thing,why deconstructivism? Why not those traditional ones?

Marjan KrebeljNikio Monday, September 7, 2009 5:57:07 AM

I guess because people always wanted to experiment with something new. Of course, this brings out many failures, but it also makes possibilities for great inventions. Just sticking to the old ways will keep you safe but it will not get you very far.

Unregistered user Tuesday, September 8, 2009 5:20:56 AM

Anonymous writes: @ Nikio thats good enough for my confusion... Can you tell me one more thing How could I relate Product or Industrial Design to Deconstructivism...? Answer is must.

Marjan KrebeljNikio Tuesday, September 8, 2009 6:45:49 AM

You can hardly speak about deconstructivism in industrial design. At least to my knowledge, so you don't have to worry about that.

If you want to know more, google Daniel Libeskind or Frank Gehry. Looking at their works will tell you enough.

Unregistered user Friday, September 25, 2009 11:00:09 PM

mariano writes: well, in my opionion deconstructivism solves the same needs than traditional style with a new language where appears new aspects such as different indeterminated limits, and fenomenological (sensorial) experiences. I'ts like a re-invention of the materials, giving them another way to build that is not the obvious complemented with big importance for sculptural shapes and artistic compositions, abstraction. once you know the material you can use it anyway and try to overcome its own limitations. try to apply the deconstructivism STYLE ('cause that's what it is) into industrial design as a concept, try to usea a different language to say what you want.... its only my point of view but i hope it helps you

Unregistered user Wednesday, October 7, 2009 9:38:24 AM

Anonymous writes: @Mariano:- Thanks... it will surely help me a lot.. Mukund

Unregistered user Tuesday, April 13, 2010 9:54:29 AM

shinil writes: hoooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

Unregistered user Friday, September 24, 2010 7:19:39 AM

Анонімний writes: If you want to buy real estate, you would have to receive the personal loans . Furthermore, my mother always takes a commercial loan, which supposes to be really rapid.

Unregistered user Sunday, October 31, 2010 12:07:55 PM

Анонімний writes: I took 1 st loan when I was 32 and that aided me a lot. But, I need the credit loan also.

Unregistered user Sunday, April 3, 2011 6:26:35 PM

Isabelle portail writes: En effet j'aime beaucoup cette architecture. C'est la lumière dans un monde magique

How to use Quote function:

  1. Select some text
  2. Click on the Quote link

Write a comment

Comment
(BBcode and HTML is turned off for anonymous user comments.)

If you can't read the words, press the small reload icon.


Smilies