Tech journalism

by Swapnil Rustagi

Why I still like the old Windows XP

Many people using Windows 7 recommend people using Windows XP to upgrade to Windows 7 and consider Windows XP obsolete. But can anyone of them really tell why to consider Windows XP obsolete? What technical improvements do Windows Vista or 7 have over Windows XP? An updated Start menu, which can be very well achieved using ViStart? Or some more eye-candy effects which can be very well achieved in Windows XP, just see http://www.askvg.com/transform-windows-xp-into-windows-7-without-using-customization-pack/

All this means that there is almost nothing in Windows 7 that can't be achieved on Windows XP. For BitLocker, there is a far superior alternative called TrueCrypt. For Snipping Tool, it has been ported to Windows XP with the use of Alky for Applications, or if you have Office 2010, just use Screen Clipping feature. For Windows Live Movie Maker, Windows Movie Maker 2.1 is still as powerful.

Let's look at the reverse side. Are there any things Windows XP can do and Windows 7 cannot. Yes, there is one thing that I know of that Windows 7 can't do; one software sending sound to multiple audio devices - see http://social.technet.microsoft.com/Forums/en-US/w7itprogeneral/thread/5861360d-53c4-4998-bc78-6c208e79e895

Also, there are more things that Windows 7 can do, but are more difficult to do than in Windows XP or require 3rd party software. One such example is of File Types tab under Folder Options. The File types tab not only allowed you to change which file extension is opened by which application, but also allowed specifying parameters for executing that application to open the file and specifying another program for when the user right-clicks the file and selects another option other than Open. This is not possible in Windows 7, except for by manually editing the registry, which can be a nuisance if you have to do it for some file extensions.

AS for other things, there are some useful features that Windows XP supported natively but Windows 7 does not and requires extra software to do. An example is ability to add password to a ZIP file is removed in Windows 7 and requires third-party software like 7-Zip, WinRAR or WinZip to do so.
A good list of features can be found at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_features_removed_in_Windows_Vista

When it comes to application compatibility, Windows XP beats Windows 7 clearly, running both old and new software without any issues. Windows XP is also the only widely used operating system today which can run with good performance on older, not so powerful hardware.

There is nothing Windows 7 can do and Windows XP can't - my reason for not upgrading to Windows 7. It's a matter of shame that Microsoft did nothing really "new" in Windows Vista and 7 except for some DirectX improvements and Windows Aero.

Microsoft - the futureOffice Web Apps Preview: Office Web Apps now better than ever

Comments

Unregistered user Wednesday, June 13, 2012 7:46:15 AM

Anonymous writes: Is there a way to port Windows 7's Paint and WordPad into Windows Vista?

Swapnil RustagiSwapnil99pro Wednesday, June 13, 2012 8:03:01 AM

^^ I will have to test it first. Please reply if you want to know about it.

Unregistered user Thursday, June 14, 2012 12:05:53 AM

Anonymous writes: ^ Thank you very much. I hope it works.

Swapnil RustagiSwapnil99pro Thursday, June 14, 2012 6:26:25 AM

^ Sorry, it didn't work. Not to mean it's impossible - but it will require wrappers for Windows 7-only Touch APIs.

You can try using Wordpad 2009 for Windows 7 like Wordpad-
https://rapidshare.com/#!download|498p10|176029454|Wordpad.2009_www.dl4all.com.rar|5584|0|0

A real port is hard to do. Sorry again.

Unregistered user Thursday, June 14, 2012 6:30:35 AM

Anonymous writes: ^ I do not quite understand. Isn't it possible to port those APIs into Vista? It does get the Ribbon API...

Unregistered user Thursday, June 14, 2012 6:53:32 AM

Anonymous writes: Mr Rustagi, please wait! I forgot to ask. Is it possible to port Aero Shake, Snap, or Peek into Windows Vista? If not, could you tell me what these features depend on in Windows 7?

Swapnil RustagiSwapnil99pro Thursday, June 14, 2012 6:58:18 AM

Originally posted by anonymous:

Isn't it possible to port those APIs into Vista? It does get the Ribbon API...


The Ribbon API is there.

To my knowledge:
However, Paint and WordPad call for some methods (C++ methods) defined only in Windows 7, for example, GetGestureInfo(). If Paint/WordPad executes on Windows Vista, then getGestureInfo() is not found inside user32.dll - therefore not allowing the program to run.

Since DLLs cannot be modified, it is important to wrap these functions and methods called by Paint and WordPad and provide them to those apps when they call it.

I have never developed a wrapper nor have any knowledge on how to do it, and while I know wrappers for backporting Vista only APIs to XP, there is no wrapper I know for backporting Windows 7 API's to Vista.

I might try to develop a wrapper later.

Unregistered user Thursday, June 14, 2012 7:15:54 AM

Anonymous writes: You are very smart! Thank you very much. I just feel bad for it because it was left out for no reason. Swapnil, do you know if it is possible to port Aero Shake, Aero Peek, and/or Aero Snap into Windows Vista? I apologize for asking twice; the only reason I am doing so is because I think that you might not have seen it, because I have problems viewing this page at times.

Swapnil RustagiSwapnil99pro Thursday, June 14, 2012 7:29:06 AM

Originally posted by anonymous:

Rustagi, do you know if it is possible to port Aero Shake, Aero Peek, and/or Aero Snap into Windows Vista?


Porting anything is possible, including the ones you asked (Aero Shake, Peek). However, it takes lots of time, effort and testing and most importantly, a very good knowledge of Win32 API functions and methods.

Only a good Windows developer (I am not a developer) with lots of time at hand can make a program to have Aero Peek and Aero Shake or Aero Snap on Windows Vista.

This, is not similar to developing a wrapper. as Aero Snap/Shake and Peek functions will never be called by Windows Vista. An application has to figure out when to call Aero Shake functions, Aero Peek functions (and these functions will have to be written by the developer).

In short, I can't do anything for now.

Unregistered user Thursday, June 14, 2012 8:52:41 AM

Anonymous writes: Thank you, Swapnil. I do apologize for answering so many questions, it's just that finding your site was a very good thing that happened to me. Hypothetically speaking, it is possible to port the new Aero features into Windows Vista so that they would be supported natively?

Swapnil RustagiSwapnil99pro Thursday, June 14, 2012 10:15:17 AM

Originally posted by anonymous:

Hypothetically speaking, it is possible to port the new Aero features into Windows Vista so that they would be supported natively?


Yes, it's possible - but you either need to have access to the source code of Windows DLLs (which only Microsoft has) or be an excellent reverse-engineer.


Unregistered user Friday, June 15, 2012 3:16:26 AM

Anonymous writes: Swapnil, may I ask one more question? Do you know how to port the Windows 95 style start menu into 7?

Unregistered user Friday, June 15, 2012 9:07:17 AM

Anonymous writes: Oh, I meant natively...

Swapnil RustagiSwapnil99pro Friday, June 15, 2012 9:12:09 AM

Originally posted by anonymous:

Anonymous writes:

Oh, I meant natively...

Not possible - until someone gets the source codes.

Unregistered user Friday, June 22, 2012 7:57:29 AM

Anonymous writes: Is there anything else from Windows 7 that will run on Windows Vista besides the Calculator?

coolweather Monday, August 20, 2012 12:20:42 PM

Just by reading your title: Yes man. I too like XP. I had windows 7 first but there was some reasons due to which I thought XP is better than 7. I'm running XP now. However it's sad to see that now about 70% users in the world use W7 :/

Swapnil RustagiSwapnil99pro Monday, August 20, 2012 12:25:54 PM

@coolweather, Thanks for the comment. Developers have valid causes to upgrade - but most users - Windows XP can do more than required.

Unregistered user Wednesday, December 19, 2012 5:03:38 PM

Anonymous writes: I'm still rocking win2000. Does everything I want.

Unregistered user Wednesday, January 23, 2013 3:44:01 PM

Anonymous writes: Let's see you index the CONTENTS of files, which you can with Windows 7. The indexing feature in Windows 7 is actually a local search engine. The truth, of course, is that you're either cheap, adverse to change, or poor (which I kinda doubt). You remind me of the folks who stuck with PC DOS because they didn't want to make the switch to Windows, or who stuck it out with Netscape Navigator because they had a woody for Bill Gates.

Unregistered user Friday, March 22, 2013 10:24:25 PM

Anonymous writes: Yeah know how you feel I loved Windows XP too and I miss it but I had a hell of a lot of problems with it and in the end I upgraded to Windows 7 kept the same tower a friend who repairs computers did it which ment the PC was gone for a week and it wasent theet expensive but Windows 7 is much better and yes from August next year Windows XP will be no more Microsoft isn't supporting it so that means your PC WILLbe very vulnerable to viruses pepole hacking your pass words and that so even though I understand you do love XP after next year you will probelly need to upgrade but changes can be good I found that so RIP windows XP hello to windows 7

How to use Quote function:

  1. Select some text
  2. Click on the Quote link

Write a comment

Comment
(BBcode and HTML is turned off for anonymous user comments.)

If you can't read the words, press the small reload icon.


Smilies