UK Wildlife Blog

Ingrebourne River Nature Reserve - bad management for water voles

The Ingrebourne Valley Nature Reserve is an important site for water voles both locally and nationally, as it is part of one of the biggest remaining populations in the country and its the first place I even saw one. Here is a (bad) photo of it back from my early days photographing wildlife.
water vole 2

It is also the best site locally for the banded demoiselle, being one of the few decent rivers in the area. Ive have walked along the bankside path with 4 or 5 taking to the air with every step.
banded demoiselle male close up

So last week when a friend told me they had done some less than sympathic work there I was quite worried. What I saw when I went there was quite shocking. The river had been dug down to an almost rectangular cross section with steep banks and all the vegetation on and between the banks removed.
ingrebourne river - not good water vole managment-4

To make matters worse the mud was just dumped on the bankside vegetation.
ingrebourne river - not good water vole managment

This was carried out for a 700m stretch, which was almost the entire length of the stretch of river in the nature reserve. Surely it should have been done in stages -if at all! Thats half a mile of river with no food or cover in the river. There is now no sign of fish in the river and perches I seen kingfishers fly from have been cut back.

Whats worse I cant see any reason for it. The nearby path did sometimes flood but there are no houses on either side for 100s of metres and they are high enough to be safe from flooding.

The question is, now water voles have an increased protection is this work recommended or even legal?

Ive looked on the DEFRA website at the law in practice water vole section (page 3 of the pdf). NE86 Water Voles - the law in practice

It states it is illegal to:

intentionally or recklessly damage, destroy or
obstruct access to any structure or place which
water voles use for shelter or protection or disturb
water voles while they are using such a place



I'm pretty sure digging out and covering their burrows and removing the plants they use for food and cover is not legal....



Update:

Turns out it was Havering council as first I suspected (its not the first time they have carried out less than sympathetic management).

I have been contacted by the local wildlife crime officer and sent them some photos and a statement. Apparently it was already being investigated.

I've also contatced Essex Wildlife Trust and they are definately aware of the situation. They in fact stopped the work once they found out what was happening, so hats of to them. Heres the quote from their facebook page in response to my question:

Yes, we are aware. As soon as we were aware of the damage we halted the work to prevent a further stretch of the river being affected. An investigation was immediately instigated. We have been working with the Environment Agency and the London Borough of Havering Council. We have also carried out our own environmental survey of the site to assess the damage and impact on the Water Voles.



Hopefully some good will come from this.

Theres another update here

mosquito pupaTame robin

Comments

Loiscakkleberrylane Wednesday, March 16, 2011 12:14:55 AM

How very sad. Terrible judgement especially in an area that claims to be a nature reserve. I'm sure nothing much can be done about this, but is there someone to appeal to that would ensure it doesn't happen again?

Adele BrandSittingFox Wednesday, March 16, 2011 9:28:21 AM

Ouch. That looks really bad. Have you contacted the reserve for an explanation?

Unregistered user Wednesday, March 16, 2011 10:52:06 AM

bigcatdetective writes: This sort of thing is going on up and down the country often by people who should know better but by publicising the damage maybe others will take note....

Dave Cdcweather Wednesday, March 16, 2011 11:01:13 AM

I'd just read about this on a fishing website Neil. Not that I
do fishing but was trying to find out which local rivers had fish so I could search for a Kingfisher. This is completely outrageous and we should write to the relevant authorities. I have a feeling it was done by the Environment Agency, a mis-noma in this case if ever there was one.

NeilUkwildlife Wednesday, March 16, 2011 11:57:25 AM

Thanks guys. Ive emailed the council and will contact Natural England and/or Environment Agency.

NeilUkwildlife Wednesday, March 16, 2011 12:05:22 PM

Based on what said on that forum looks like it was the EA.

Unregistered user Friday, March 18, 2011 2:56:10 PM

The Brickfield Birder writes: I'm please to see the vandals were I.D'd I hope some action is taken. I am a member of Essex Wildlife Trust and I am pleased to see them being involved. I am also a ratepayer of the said council and I shall be contacting my local councillor for an explanation! Truly angry and upset by this damage. It's too late now for 'sorry' the damage is done. However long term it will recover. The ignorance of wildlife and habit's beggars belief from some local councils. On the brighter side, great site with lovely photos, keep them coming !

NeilUkwildlife Friday, March 18, 2011 6:32:42 PM

@Brickfield birder. Thanks for your comment and kind words about the site. I believe a fair number of us locals are rather annoyed by this and not just wildlife fans but fishermen also. Hopefully Havering Council will sort their act out after this.

Dave Cdcweather Saturday, March 19, 2011 2:57:51 PM

So was it the Council or the EA who did this?

NeilUkwildlife Saturday, March 19, 2011 8:58:47 PM

Havering council based on what the EWT said.

Dave Cdcweather Sunday, March 20, 2011 8:30:48 PM

Asbo required I think!

Unregistered user Friday, April 6, 2012 10:20:02 PM

Martin H writes: I'm pleased to say I saw a water vole on the Ingrebourne today - but this was further north, just up past the Upminster Golf Club. How is the River Park recovering from the council vandelism last year?

Dave Cdcweather Sunday, April 8, 2012 10:00:06 AM

I've not been to have a look yet but a year on I hope to soon. I will keep you posted. Thanks, Dave.

Dave Cdcweather Sunday, April 8, 2012 10:02:58 AM

Those kind of problems seem common. There was a similar issue in the Mardyke Valley last year where over enthusiastic contractors cut down reeds and nettles right down to the waters edge in the middle of summer, completely destroying the bankside habitat. The Warden said they thought they were doing him a favour by doing the extra to what he had asked for!!

Unregistered user Friday, May 4, 2012 3:44:47 PM

writes: The river is doing OK, and since the dredging, there has been further work done on the river but this time in line with what the Essex Wildlife trust has suggested. The river has been re profiled in some places, and also some backwater channels have been added. New water Vole Holes have also been spotted in the dredged section of the river. So nature is recovering back to its former glory, if not better with the new soft engineering which the council has put in place to improve bio-diversity!

Unregistered user Sunday, January 27, 2013 9:27:54 AM

AndyH writes: I notice that further dredging and bank works are being carried out on our little gem of a river around the Shepherds Hill bridge. Does anyone know if the relevant wildlife bodies have been consulted?

Unregistered user Sunday, January 27, 2013 9:35:01 AM

AndyH writes: Has anyone else noticed the green parrots in Harold Wood Park.

Dave Cdcweather Sunday, January 27, 2013 10:46:29 PM

I haven't but they will be Ring Necked Parakeets.

How to use Quote function:

  1. Select some text
  2. Click on the Quote link

Write a comment

Comment
(BBcode and HTML is turned off for anonymous user comments.)

If you can't read the words, press the small reload icon.


Smilies