Skip navigation.

Software Development

Correcting The Future

K4: Part I

Kryptos sculpture at CIA.

My partial solution to Kryptos.

Before I begin, I need to mention that I don't have the final solution and am no longer interested in obtaining it. Perhaps I'm wrong. I hope I am and I'll need some humility going forward. But if what I present here is in any way true, then I want no part of the final solution. I may still look at it from time to time. I know where the next part is and know some of the details for deciphering it. But my interest just isn't there anymore. You'll see why as we move along. The beginning is very interesting. There is even a clue at the end that I found quite intriguing, even fun. But it only confirmed my worst fears. I once had a comment that I was climbing mountains. I think that comment should be redirected at Sanborn if the following XI part series is true. It's crMzy what's here. You will see exactly WHY, or should I say C exJctYL Y it's never been cracked, and why I leave this here for others to C. Annoying, isn't it? But like I said, the first parts are quite entertaining.

(edit: The following articles are what I've found in a two week span. These were the last two weeks of May 2009. At the beginning of May 2009, I didn't even know what a Ceasar shift was. I then went through the US Army's manual on cryptography and brushed up on field ciphers. At the same time, I was reading what I could on the sculputre itself, but no work was being done to decipher it. The last two weeks of May would bring new clues on a daily basis. At the end, I could no longer entertain the notion that I was on the right track since everything was getting really absurd. Here is the result of what I found if anyone cares to completely solve K4.)

PART I

The Russians are coming

One thing to remember about any creative art is that it's rare for something to be done for nothing. This is obvious to anyone who's done manual labour. If you read up on how Sanborn made the sculpture, he talks about how it took several months to cut out the letters with a jigsaw. I don't understand how that is even possible, but I can guarantee, you won't be doing more cutting than you need.

Just think as to what it would take to include something useless. Think about putting useless Morse code on your sculpture. For people who work at programming or use a computer, you can try different things without much loss of time and effort. But when you have anything creative, whether it be a book, story, sculpture or anything else, thinking up of useless things to include doesn't make much sense. The effort you put into it would be wasted. Also, how do you think up of useless thing to put into your work? Seems rather backwards.

So everything at the site serves a purpose. Those that don't serve a practical purpose serve an aesthetic purpose.

I hope everyone understands by now that no one is going to put Morse code there for no reason. Not ONE letter, not one dot or dash is going to be cut out if it's not needed. A mistake that's left in if it's aesthetically pleasing to save from starting over? Sure. But nothing intentional.

Now that we know EVERYTHING is important, let's list the things that stand out.

  1. X's in K2.
  2. LAYERTWO
  3. K4 is 31 characters wide on its last three rows.
  4. Tableau has 4 extra columns.
  5. X CAN YOU SEE ANYTHING Q
  6. Misspelled words IQLUSION, UNDERGRUUND and DESPARATLY.

I could go on, but this is enough.

Let's start with #1. X's. Also consider that the misspelled U in UNDERGRUUND should be an O. X's and O's? Not only that, but K3 is done in a Morse code style transmission, as stated by K2. K2 says that it was gathered and transmitted underground. The landscaping has copper plating that goes underground. The copper plating has Morse code. So making the link, K3 and K4 are symbolically underground. They are buried. Dark. K3 is almost invisible and K4 is completely invisible. More on that later.

Let's stick with the X's and O's. We know that K3 is done in Morse code style. In Morse code, you're supposed to start a message by sending the station ID that you want to contact, the letters DE followed by your own ID.

SLOWLY DE SPARATLY

Or, if we cut it off at the missing E,

SLOWLY DE SPARAT

Does SPARAT remind you of anything?

SPARTA by flipping the last two characters. This is itself a clue for later. See, the clue are stumbling over themselves.

Also in Morse code is that '?' is sent to correct a word. In this case, the last thing sent is not a word, but the letter Q.

X CAN YOU SEE ANYTHING Q ? O (BKR...)

Is it getting clearer? The Q was a mistake, or a misspelling if you will that is beneficial in being there as a clue. Corrected with the O, we get

X CAN YOU SEE ANYTHING O

Or, CAN YOU SEE ANYTHING between the X's and O's.

It should be clear that the most famous game of X's and O's is tic tac toe. It's a clear indication of a grid or matrix. But what kind? Nihilist, checkerboard, polybius, playfair, two squares, four squares? What? Lots of options.

Well, on the tableau, we have a 30 letter alphabet in the top row. What kind of grid has 30 characters?

Straddling Checkerboard!

That's a Russian invention.

So we put our Russian thinking caps on. When in Russia, do as the Russian, uh..., do.

How do Russians build straddling checkerboards? In WWII, they had a specific way of building them.

They have more letters in their alphabet, but the principle is the same when converted to English. You pick the most common letters for the top row. Then pick a keyword and write it out horizontally removing any duplicate letters. Then write the remaining letters of the alphabet underneath in alphabetic order. In English, we'd need 28 characters in all, so we add a period and question mark.

In English, we'd have three rows which means two spots on the top row are blank. What 8 letters should be use for the top row?

Remember DYAHR? The letters that are offset? That's a feature of Linotype machines. It's why all typesetting programs have offset letters in their logos. It's also called HOT TYPE. If you see a resemblance to HOT AIR, then you might be starting to see how K3 fits into all this.

Linotype machines had two groups of 6 letters which contained the most used letters.

ETAOIN SHDRLU

We still have a problem. Those are 6 letter groups. Not 8 like we need.

I originally started with SHDRLU because of LAYERTWO. But with what I know now, that may not have been entirely correct. Still, I ended up with a correct matrix.

SHDRLU

What other two characters should we use?

In K3, there is

I MADE A TINY BREACH IN THE UPPER LEFT CORNER.

In the upper left corner of the K3 ciphertext is EN. And both letters happen to be part of the first group. So I decided to give those 8 letters a try.

SHDRLUEN

What about the keyword? KRYPTOS seems as good a keyword as any. So we start with KRYPTOS and write the rest of the alphabet underneath with a period and question mark as well.

K  R  Y  P  T  O  S


A  B  C  D  E  F  G


H  I  J  L  M  N  Q


U  V  W  X  Z  .  ?



Now, we number our 8 letters SHDRLUEN from 0 to 7 in columnar order from left to right. So we scan KAHU then RBIV, etc. and number our 8 letters as we find them.

K  R  Y  P  T  O  S
   2              7

A  B  C  D  E  F  G
         3  5

H  I  J  L  M  N  Q
0        4     6

U  V  W  X  Z  .  ?
1


The remaining letters are numbered from 10 to 29 using the same columnar traversal.


K  R  Y  P  T  O  S
10 2  15 19 21 24 7

A  B  C  D  E  F  G
11 12 16 3  5  25 27

H  I  J  L  M  N  Q
0  13 17 4  22 6  28

U  V  W  X  Z  .  ?
1  14 18 20 23 26 29


Now we extract the letters according to their number. We leave number 8 and 9 as blank for now. Also, each 10 letters go on a different row. That will make three rows in all.

HURDLENS
KABIVYCJWP
XTMZOF.GQ?


If that doesn't impress you, I don't know what will. The last part to finishing the straddling checkerboard is to figure out what spots to leave blank in the top row. We'll talk about that in part II.

For now, note the 'X' and 'Q?' Also note HURD LENS. It's a kind of contact lens. TMZ OF could also be considered a clue (TMZ is found on the last line of K4's ciphertext). See VYC. I had long suspected it had something to do with a VIC cipher. But that's for a much later section.

Part 1 to K4 of Kryptos Solved! (Update: Aug 3, 2009)K4: Part II

Comments

Kryptos Fan 19. July 2009, 04:43

I'm no expert but I was under the impression that Q was added into K3 by those deciphering it because "?" are not usually used during encryption with transpositions. I like the way you start because it involves an actual ciphering method. It's easy for folks to get creative and come up some crazy method of their own. An impression during my first read-through is that SHDRLUEN is perhaps a bit arbitrary but I'll hold that verdict until I can get further in.

I'm concerned because of your disclaimer that you haven't found the plaintext of K4 but what you have found has soured any further interest in it. Nice foreshadowing though, definitely makes me want to keep reading!

Vorlath 20. July 2009, 06:08

The Q is actually in K3.

Anonymous 24. November 2009, 08:49

knight writes:

im no genius at this, new actually. but maybe from the first three mispelled which you seem to have corrected maybe it can read as:

illusion
underground
sparta

maybe it relates to the illuminati?
the truth will be revealed as always sed, maybe this krypto is a warning of where things may come from?
have you tried cross referencing these mispelled words with the ancient latin language?
have you tried reversing the entire krypto?
or maybe reading it from i believe the arabic and asia perspective....right to left?

Anonymous 25. November 2009, 06:45

knight writes:

any answers yet or has these methods been tried already?

Vorlath 25. November 2009, 18:01

Illusion and underground are obviously the correct words. Sparta is mentioned in the article. I doubt it would relate to the illuminati just because I don't think Sanborn would go into conspiracy territory with a contract from the CIA.

Sanborn also said it was in English. But right to left may be possible since there seems to be a lot of clues leading to this. The Morse code must be read facing south. The word END appears at the beginning of K3's ciphertext.

I did try the VIC cipher and found some words come out, but I know it's not the correct algorithm. It may have been encoded in such a way to provide clues. But it was said that K4 was meant to be solved with pen and paper in a straightforward manner.

How to use Quote function:

  1. Select some text
  2. Click on the Quote link

Write a comment

Comment
(BBcode and HTML is turned off for anonymous user comments.)

If you can't read the words, press the small reload icon.


Smilies

December 2009
S M T W T F S
November 2009January 2010
1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31