The My Opera forums have been replaced with forums.opera.com. Please head over there to discuss Opera's products and features

See the new Forums

Enhanced content blocker

Forums » Opera for Windows/Mac/Linux » Desktop wish-list

You need to be logged in to post in the forums. If you do not have an account, please sign up first.

Go to last post

4. December 2011, 17:42:30

exzentrik

Posts: 48

Enhanced content blocker

It would be great to have an option in the content blocker to block specific ad servers only for specific domains. Example: I want to block Adition.com-ads not globally, but only on (a) specific website(s). Or is this already possible?

Adblock Plus has such filter attributes, but I don't want to use any third party extensions and hope for an content blocker enhancement.

4. December 2011, 18:49:42

serious

Now also on Vivaldi

Posts: 5658

what for?
All my posts only represent my own opinions.
[ Tweedo Monitor - Deluxe Website & Service Monitoring ]

4. December 2011, 19:33:16

exzentrik

Posts: 48

As I said: "... to block specific ad servers only for specific domains."

I don't like excessive ad blocking, cause many websites are financially dependent on ads. I only block really annoying ads.

7. December 2011, 07:18:57

derDay

Posts: 2367

you can exclude ad blocking at the site-specific options
in use: Opera 12.14 Build 1738 x64 JRE 1.7.0_51-b13 x64 Flash 12.0.0.43 x64 @ Win7 Home x64 SP1

7. December 2011, 09:52:26

exzentrik

Posts: 48

Yes, but that's too unhandy.

5. January 2012, 14:11:05

aparente001

Posts: 103

Personally I am an extremely aggressive ad blocker. Ads are very hard on my eyes and my brain. I like using the internet, but I think society (in my case, the US government, using tax money) should subsidize journalism for the public good. I figure, as long as I am politically active to promote that, I don't have to feel guilty about not supporting business models that get adopted because journalism is not subsidized. I'm not explaining that very well, I hope you see what I'm trying to say.

I don't have any experience with third party extensions in opera (although I have used them in firefox) -- I didn't know they exist, and I don't know how to! Can you talk about your reluctance? I wonder if I should get my head out of the sand.

5. January 2012, 18:01:33 (edited)

exzentrik

Posts: 48

Originally posted by aparente001:

Can you talk about your reluctance? I wonder if I should get my head out of the sand.



Well, most of the websites are free because of the ads. And if the majority of the readers is blocking all ads - even the unintrusive ones, like banners - the free websites getting in financial problems. The sideeffects of this are saving measures, which are leading to overstrained editors, bad researches and a general loss in quality. And in the end, the magazines have to close their doors or make a part of their contents for subscribers only. Another example: Even print magazines couldn't exist without ads. It's elemental.

So, as long as the ads are unintrusive and doesn't bother me with sound, layers or other methods, I accept them. AdBlock Plus has made a important step in the right direction with his "non-intrusive ads"-feature, which is enabled by default. I wish that a similiar feature will be available in Opera in the future - without the need of any third party extension.

5. January 2012, 17:20:00

mve88

Posts: 16

I want this


7. January 2012, 06:07:03

aparente001

Posts: 103

I meant can you talk about your reluctance to use a third party extension? I know nothing about them.

7. January 2012, 13:46:15

exzentrik

Posts: 48

Originally posted by aparente001:

I meant can you talk about your reluctance to use a third party extension? I know nothing about them.



I just don't like third party software in Opera. It's an all in one-solution for me. I rather propose new features instead of using a third party extension. Furthermore, a third party extension could introduce bugs or security holes/risks, especially if it is based on NPAPI (which is at least the case at Chrome and Firefox). You can read more about here:

http://support.google.com/chrome_webstore/bin/answer.py?hl=en&hlrm=de&answer=186213&rd=1

Forums » Opera for Windows/Mac/Linux » Desktop wish-list