MAMA: W3C validator research

Forums » Dev.Opera » Archived Article Discussions

This topic has been closed. No new entries allowed.

Reason: You can now post comments on articles on Dev Opera

Forum rules and guidelines

You need to be logged in to post in the forums. If you do not have an account, please sign up first.

15. October 2008, 00:21:56

blooberry

Posts: 13

MAMA: W3C validator research



( Read the article )

21. October 2008, 15:07:27

mf55

Posts: 19

Regarding findings of DOCTYPE present or not: The standards specify that DOCTYPE is the first statement in a document. So the validator should report an error in any other case, yet it seems there are cases where it does not.

Should MAMA improve on the validator and report this as a validator error?

23. October 2008, 19:33:22

blooberry

Posts: 13

Actually, if I remember correctly, the validator gets this right. It is MAMA that looks anywhere in the document for a Doctype, while the validator only checks at the beginning of the document. The discrepancy between the validator's doctype count and MAMA's count give some measure of just how many documents don't put the doctype at the beginning of the document (~3% in MAMA's URL set)

20. April 2009, 15:19:14

daniiswara

Posts: 6

May I know the best cms/web/blog with typo3 which has valid xhtml, proper use of semantics, or accessibility? I can't find it on Google yet.

22. April 2009, 14:41:40

Erinyes

the Reasoner.

Posts: 378

<b>daniiswara</b>: I don't think more statistics then has been released will be released (if the archives are even that conprehensive as to generate them).

Concerning the "error extremes" on page 3, it should be noted there is such a thing as a error cascade, especially in validators; just fixing one error sometimes solves twenty, for example.
Just as I thought...

23. April 2009, 06:56:21

yafan99

Posts: 1

W3C validator

23. April 2009, 22:12:19

Erinyes

the Reasoner.

Posts: 378

Originally posted by yafan99:

W3C validator

http://validator.w3.org/
http://jigsaw.w3.org/css-validator/
Just as I thought...

Forums » Dev.Opera » Archived Article Discussions