Skip navigation.

Slightly ajar

Vista/IE7 breaks the Korean web industry

, ,

I'm not sure if anyone here is familiar with the state of the Korean web industry, but I've just read a very interesting blog post on Engadget, related to an issue Opera and the Open the Web team know far too well:

South Korea's Ministry of Information and Communication, Ministry of Government Administration and Home Affairs, and Financial Supervisory Service have all come out against widespread Vista upgrades, advising Joe Consumer -- er, Kim Consumer -- to hold off on upgrading until ActiveX compatibility issues can be worked out. Apparently banks, portals, online games and online shops have relied a bit too heavily on the sometimes insecure ActiveX controls, and are scrambling to make their sites compatible with Windows Vista's new approach to ActiveX. Microsoft has been working with banking services and others to promote compatibility, but the changes are taking longer than it expected, and its not delaying the OS further to appease the stragglers. So the best the South Korean institutions can do is issue said warnings and hope for the best when the 31st rolls around.

Korea has a huge issue with web compatibility. Most sites use Active-X, and even if they don't the majority rely on IE bugs and quirks, instead of following the standards. Looking at almost all of the top sites in any none-IE browser is like looking at a page after it has went through a blender, with mis-placed elements everywhere, and missing content. If IE7 made all of its changes in quirks mode as well as standards mode the Korean web industry would be in even bigger trouble. We've been trying to contact Korean web sites for a long time to fix their sites, but they were either not interested (market share) or didn't reply. There are also grass roots level organisations like OpenWeb Korea that have been trying to combat this problem. Maybe the Korean government and the industry as a whole will realise what we've been trying to tell them all a long -- that relying on one browser, not following standards, and using vendor specific extensions is folly and it will cost you in the end.

Maybe the government should start promoting these open standards now to avoid issues such as this in the future. What will IE8 bring for example? How are you going to get sites to run on mobile, where IE is not king and Active-X or VBScript doesn't exist? How many more Won will it cost the country each time these issues surface? I'm not sure who from Microsoft they are working with to fix these issues, or who Microsoft is talking to, but we have a lot of experience with the problems are facing. We have many issues already found, analysed and suggested fixes ready. We'd love to work with Korea to get their web sites into the 21st century and away from vendor lock-in, so the offer still stands. If any site want to work with us on fixing their issues then get i touch with me and we'll only be too happy to help

Web chat with yours trulyCreating buttons without images using CSS3

Comments

jdevalk 24. January 2007, 20:38

Hmmm, web standards should be obliged by law for banking sites etc., that'd save a lot of hassle P:

rmccabe916 24. January 2007, 21:48

Yep. I love Bank of America's slogan though, "Higher Standards," yet their website doesn't seem to follow them. :rolleyes:

b_laudanum 24. January 2007, 22:13

IE7 sucks!
that's why I love my Suse!

p:

FataL 24. January 2007, 22:45

I wonder what is percentage of IE usage in Korea? Around 99%?!
Let more people know about that - digg!

dstorey 24. January 2007, 22:47

It has greater than 99.5% last time I heard. And the percentage was growing. It has total monopoly in Korea. Must be pretty much impossible to use a Mac or Linux in Korea, unless you just surf foreign web sites.

kazuhito 25. January 2007, 00:44

Interesting. That's why I gave a presentation about web standards at SOFT EXPO 2006 & DCF in Seoul last year - the title was "Web Standards: The Right Tool for the Right Job". I think KIPA has already known how standards are important, so here I'm a bit optimistic, though.

dstorey 25. January 2007, 01:40

I believe there is some form of legislation in place about open standards, and an official stance on supporting Open Source. But IE market share has gone up since and nothing has been enforced in regards to requiring sites to be accessible in other browsers. Lets hope KIPA start doing the right thing.

Kazuhito: do you have the slides for your presentation. It would be nice to be able to promote them when talking to site owners and developers. I think that conference may have been the one Mike Smith attended and presented at. We'd love to help KIPA promote standards and assist the sites with their issues. It is probably something WaSP can help with too, with the International Liaison Group. Sites like CSS Forum Korea and Korea Web Accessibility Group will be especially helpful at spreading the word and supplying good advice to new and established web designers in Korea. There is certainly a lot we can start to become positive about.

kazuhito 25. January 2007, 05:06

Anonymous 26. January 2007, 08:56

Gen Kanai writes:

I've covered this topic in a lot more detail on my blog.

http://www.kanai.net/weblog/archive/2007/01/26/00h53m55s

Anonymous 26. January 2007, 23:07

ricky writes:

Yeah, I gave up on doing e-banking with a Korean bank (my wife is Korean) when I saw the hassle: be Administrator, install dozens of active-X in order to finally have an encrypted http which was basically doing the same like https.

Anonymous 27. January 2007, 14:34

Coenraad de Beer writes:

I hope other IE Exclusive sites will learn from the mistakes of the South Koreans.

http://cybertopcops.blogspot.com/2007/01/designing-ie-exclusive-sites-is.html

The time has come for designers to realise how important it is to comply with web standards.

Anonymous 25. May 2007, 03:19

Gene writes:

Yea I agree,

plethora of Korean websites, i.e. major broadcasting company websites do NOT work on Firefox.

Evenworse: Try surfing Korean gov't websites, i.e. Ministry of justice @ moj.go.kr with firefox.

Lots of things don't work

ridiculous. it's about damn time they get their heads out of the sand.

How to use Quote function:

  1. Select some text
  2. Click on the Quote link

Write a comment

Comment
(BBcode and HTML is turned off for anonymous user comments.)

Type the two words displayed in the image below:


Smilies