Standards compliance victim
Friday, 14. October 2005, 13:29:22
Coming soon to a screen near you!
New software drama, Standards compliance victim, starring:
Question of the day is: why does the "news slideshow" on AOL's front page run ten times too fast in Opera?
Because FireFox's implementation of DOM2Events has serious shortcomings, as I've mentioned earlier. AOL.com is the latest and most high-profile site that has run into this problem so far.
On AOL's main page the small "slideshow" runs much faster than it is supposed to, the "play/pause/next" buttons do not work, you get strange alerts about content not being available, and the whole page makes Opera use a lot of CPU resources. This is all because they use a capturing "load" event listener when they meant to use a non-capturing one.
It works in FireFox because it does not support capturing event listeners. It fails in Opera because we follow the spec.
I've written a couple of pages to show the difference. Try these in FireFox and Opera:
Since I have written the test cases, could someone do me a favour and make sure there is a Bugzilla report on the second issue? I know bug 235441 covers the former.
New software drama, Standards compliance victim, starring:
- The browser who got it right
- The Spec
- The browser who got it wrong
- The site that got it totally wrong but thinks everything is ok
Question of the day is: why does the "news slideshow" on AOL's front page run ten times too fast in Opera?
Because FireFox's implementation of DOM2Events has serious shortcomings, as I've mentioned earlier. AOL.com is the latest and most high-profile site that has run into this problem so far.
On AOL's main page the small "slideshow" runs much faster than it is supposed to, the "play/pause/next" buttons do not work, you get strange alerts about content not being available, and the whole page makes Opera use a lot of CPU resources. This is all because they use a capturing "load" event listener when they meant to use a non-capturing one.
It works in FireFox because it does not support capturing event listeners. It fails in Opera because we follow the spec.
I've written a couple of pages to show the difference. Try these in FireFox and Opera:
- FireFox doesn't get it 1: capturing listeners should not fire on target
- FireFox doesn't get it 2: loading progress bar demo
Since I have written the test cases, could someone do me a favour and make sure there is a Bugzilla report on the second issue? I know bug 235441 covers the former.
You must be logged in to write a comment. if you're not a registered member, please 
By feldgendler, # 17. October 2005, 11:18:41
By hallvors, # 18. October 2005, 10:29:39
Great tools on your Homepage! Thanks!
By ycc2106, # 21. October 2005, 13:12:24
By hallvors, # 3. November 2005, 19:23:05
- removeEventlistener doesn't prevent the removed event listener from being called when the event is being processed (bug 220773).
- Opera doesn't know what unload is (bug 220772) !
By xErath, # 18. July 2006, 00:37:50