Monday, 19. January 2009, 14:45:21
Last week I wrote a blog post with some critics to Israels actions. I'm glad to have heard there is been agreed with a ceasefire by both parties. After loosing the lives of thirteen Israeli (of which three civilian) and more than 1250 Palestinians, of which more than half were civilians according to the UN, hopefully no more lives will be lost in these useless fights.
Still after this last post, a lot of you seemed not to agree with my statements. Even being a bit upset. Well, I have to agree I might have sketched the situation a little black and white. Of course as always things are covered in shades of gray, but to give a clear picture of my point, I simplified certain things. It doesn't mean I don't agree with what I said earlier, but I feel compelled to clarify my meaning.
I believe many people have a wrong idea of the situation. What Israel really is, whether Palestinians are terrorist or a nationality. I don't blame you for that, I didn't knew, nobody tells you, so if you're not sure about how it is, please try to find some factual information. You can read something like
Wikipedia on this subject if you doubt me.

Let me again give you in short how it is. Before Israel ever existed, there was a country called British Mandate of Palestine. We are now at the beginning of the 20th century. Some Jews decided it was a good idea to go and live in this land, these people were called Zionists. The number of allowed migrants were kept limited, because it wasn't to much fun for those already live there getting all these migrants.
In 1947 the land was divided in two states one Arab one Jewish, so still one land. Instead of try to live like this for a while, the Jewish state declared independence in 1948, which the Arabs didn't like because the land which was part of the Jewish state was also their heritage and they always lived there. Nevertheless Israel (from then a new nation) started war against the Arabs, separating from them and even annexing parts of the Arab parts.
Normally we would call Israel the oppressor in a case like this, and the Arabs would be the suppressed people. Really I don't see how you can explain it otherwise.
So when you claim Israel has the right to defend themselves against terrorist attacks, you're claim would be really doubtful. First of all Israel is the offensive side, so speaking of defending is a bit strange. Second speaking about terrorist would be wrong, it's just a political opponent calling it terrorism is choosing side. Just like [URL=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrorist}Wikepedia says it:
The concept of terrorism is itself controversial because it is often used by states to delegitimize political opponents, and thus legitimize the state's own use of terror against those opponents.
Lets continue, as I already said it's hard to see Israel as a nation on it's own without Palestinian arias. They are part of the same land. Just look at the map.
It is unreasonable to expect Palestinians to live in a prison like this. You know they can't move normally in their own land, when they go to work, to family, or anywhere, if they are even allowed they have to spend hours to reach their destination without it being far away.
They are economically cut off.
Piotr ask:
Please tell me why have Hamas terrorists dug underground tunels between Israel and Palestinian border? Because of friendship? Are they going to send flowers to Israel?
Let me answer your question. They have been cut off, isolated, imprisoned. That's why they are digging tunnels. And about the flowers... They do cultivate flowers in Palestine, but they can't export them because they have to go through Israel. So actually they could dig the tunnel to send flowers

I think a lot of people would be surprised if they read the facts. The image drawn out for you by the media, by governments and Israel itself of course, is very much wrong from the real picture. Please feel free to form your own opinion, but make sure you know some facts around this issue!
Then concerning the US influence among this conflict.
Karma wrote her concerns that information around the subject wasn't correct, let me comment on that by some quotes (again quite some wikipedia, yes I know I use it a lot for reference in this article...)
Hopefully I don't upset you to much here
Karma:
Woah..woah...!!!Everyone here has this information wrong. I am a native of the United States and we are not on the Isralies side of anything, and no one and I do mean no one controls the United States except the United States.
Wikipedia:
The United States Congress places considerable importance on the maintenance of a close and supportive relationship. The main expression of support for Israel has been foreign aid, which Congress monitors closely along with other issues in bilateral relations. Congressional concerns have affected different Administration's policies over the last 60 years.
You can read more on Wikipedia.
Karma:
Everyone needs to look toward China about the weapons that the Isralies are using. We have since closed our borders in trade with China because of this.
Wikipedia:
The nation's military relies heavily on high-tech weapons systems designed and manufactured in Israel as well as some foreign imports. The United States is a particularly notable foreign contributor; they are expected to provide the country with $30 billion in military aid between 2008 and 2017.[163] The Israeli- and U.S.-designed Arrow missile is one of the world's only operational anti-ballistic missile systems.[164]
And again
Wikipedia:
On July 14, the US Congress was notified of a potential sale of $210 million worth of jet fuel to Israel. The Defense George Bush Security Cooperation Agency noted that the sale of the JP-8 fuel, should it be completed, will "enable Israel to maintain the operational capability of its aircraft inventory." and "The jet fuel will be consumed while the aircraft is in use to keep peace and security in the region."[9] It was reported in 24 July that the United States was in the process of providing Israel with "bunker buster" bombs, which would allegedly be used to target the leader of Lebanon's Hezbollah guerilla group and destroy its trenches.[10]
American media also recently questioned whether Israel had violated an agreement not to use American-supplied cluster bombs on civilian targets. Evidence during the conflict had shown that cluster bombs had been used in civilian areas, and several bomb particles remained undetonated after the war causing hazard for Lebanese civilians. Israel has responded to these accusations by saying that it had not violated any international law.[11]
About China
it says:
Over the years, the United States and Israel have regularly discussed Israel's sale of sensitive security equipment and technology to various countries, especially the People's Republic of China. U.S. administrations believe that such sales are potentially harmful to the security of U.S. forces in Asia.
So Israel is selling your US weapons to China. That's real nice of them isn't it?
Karma:
We are still at war with the middle east, our husbands,fathers,brothers,daughters,wives and sons are there and dying for their country and what ever country that has called upon us. We are a civil,peaceful,patient and powerful country and we try to converse with these countries to find the best solution to try to prevent going to war and sometimes it takes a long time and sometimes war is the only solution. We go to other countries aid BUT who comes to the United States aid, huh?
Yes I know, and it is especially a great gesture by those men that are fighting there. Nevertheless you could ask your government why you fighting those particular wars. People of Iraq didn't really ask for it (and understand me well, that doesn't mean they are not glad with your help), but I can imagine they are a bit doubtful about there oil leaping out the country all the sudden.
Unfortunately here are a lot more wars you can 'choose' from, just look to central Africa. Why don't we hear anyone about the killings of millions of people over there? Not interesting enough for ourselves?
Globalpolicy.orgThe four giant firms located in the US and the UK have been keen to get back into Iraq, from which they were excluded with the nationalization of 1972. During the final years of the Saddam era, they envied companies from France, Russia, China, and elsewhere, who had obtained major contracts. But UN sanctions (kept in place by the US and the UK) kept those contracts inoperable. Since the invasion and occupation of Iraq in 2003, much has changed. In the new setting, with Washington running the show, "friendly" companies expect to gain most of the lucrative oil deals that will be worth hundreds of billions of dollars in profits in the coming decades. The Iraqi constitution of 2005, greatly influenced by US advisors, contains language that guarantees a major role for foreign companies.
And of course those weapons of mass destruction that weren't found.....
Let me remind that US is not the only one. Europe is happy to join in this 'heist'.
Karma:
We defend us.
Great! Against what exactly?
Karma:
What ever news that is broadcasting this dribble to their people are not reporting the truth. Do you think that we would sell or trade weapons to a country that is at war with us? Come on people, get the facts and truth right. I have more to wright but im upset now so i'll leave it at what it is dribble.
Since Israel is an ally and not an enemy, it's not so strange to provide them with weapons.
One last thing I would like to say. I think the US tends to be so arrogant thinking they can tell the rest of the world what they should do, but at the same time they have a very narrow perspective on how the rest of the world might think. Having no clue what's happening outside the USA.
Of course this is my general impression, there are exceptions, and I have no doubt of all the good intentions of it's citizens. And I mean that, so the last few lines might give the idea I hate Americans, but its absolutely not the case. I like the most!
Sorry for the long, boring post. Feel free to respond.