Skip navigation.

Log in | Sign up

photo of Matthew

Noah Counte

Hanging around in a one horse town

Of Debates and Town Halls

,

The McCain and Obama camps have agreed to a format for all three debates. Debates aren’t a given (though there has been at least one for every election since 1960), and do not happen at all, until the two candidates (three, when there is a “viable” third party candidate – viva Ross Perot!) agree on a format. Historically, the formats have been pretty formulaic, but it looks as though we are in for a bit of fun, this time around.

The nonpartisan Commission on Presidential Debates, which is sponsoring the forums, brokered the agreements. Agreements, because there will be a different format for the vice presidential debates. More on that later.

The first Presidential debate will cover foreign policy and the third debate will cover economic/domestic issues. There will be a second debate too, as you might have guessed, which will be a town hall type meeting where the candidates will answer questions from the audience and off the internet on any topic. Each of the three will be 90 minutes long.

The debate over format and specifics has been relatively without pouting, as far as I can tell. No one has complained about potential camera angles (really, it’s been bickered about in the past) lectern heights, or message lights, and, except for the order of the debates, there has been general agreement about length and format. Neither Obama nor McCain became personally involved in hammering out the details.

The first and third Presidential Debates will be a much more free-form exercise than is usual. If you remember past elections, there would be a question from the moderator, a timed response, a shorter rebuttal, and sometimes an even shorter re-rebuttal. This time around, there will be a question asked, and then each candidate will have two minutes to answer. After that, they’ll hammer on each other, mixing it up for five minutes. They’ll stand behind lecterns at the first debate, and site at a round table for the third. At the town hall meeting, they’ll sit on stools.

The schedule looks like this:

  • First debate
    Sept. 26 at University of Mississippi
    Topic: Foreign policy and national security
    Moderator: Jim Lehrer of PBS
    Staging: Podiums
    Format: Broken into nine 9-minute segments. The moderator will introduce a topic and allow each candidate 2 minutes to comment, then facilitate a discussion for the remaining 5 minutes.
  • Second debate
    Oct. 7 at Belmont University in Nashville.
    Moderator: Tom Brokaw of NBC
    Staging: Town hall
    Format: The moderator will call on members of the audience (and draw questions from the Internet). Each candidate will have 2 minutes to respond to each question. Following those initial answers, the moderator will invite the candidates to respond to the previous answers, for a total of 1 minute.
  • Third debate
    Oct. 15 at Hofstra University in Hempstead, N.Y.
    Topic: Domestic and economic policy
    Moderator:Bob Schieffer of CBS
    Staging: Seated at a table
    Format: Same as first presidential debate, plus each candidate will get a 90-second closing statement.

The Vice Presidential debates will be much more tightly run, with no interplay between the candidates. Camp McCain is worried about Palin’s lack of debating experience. Camp Obama, on the other hand, is worried about Biden’s propensity to ramble on – and that the more he talks, the more likely he is to say something that might come back to bite them on the heinie.

There you have it. Watch the debates - they should be interesting, informative, and maybe seminal in defining the candidates, this time more than usual.

Some Days, You're Just Too BusyOf Gas and Governors

Comments

Ripp 21. September 2008, 02:17

Nice post bro!!!

Personally, I would have more fun listening to my own gas than listening to the gas they are going to spew from their mouths...

:whistle:

:devil:

Matthew 21. September 2008, 02:38

lol That's the gas that's going to make this country go (or not) for a while.

I'm with you, though. SO far, it's been a lot of hot air and finger pointing.

Ripp 21. September 2008, 03:17

:eyes: Yes, it seems in the last 4 elections the % of bullshit flying from the mouths of the candidates goes up 10,000 times each election. What happened to honesty, morals, etc... Fucking losers!!!

:devil:

Matthew 21. September 2008, 03:18

Deja moo. Same old BS all over again.

Ripp 21. September 2008, 03:45

:lol:

Matthew 21. September 2008, 03:51

I wish that was mine - it's pretty funny :lol:

Aadil 21. September 2008, 12:13

:Yawn:

Donny 21. September 2008, 16:27

very informative. I really like the reasons stated for the VP debates. Such good reasons.

Matthew 22. September 2008, 00:11

Thanks, Donny. I think they'll be seminal, but in politics, one shouldn't be surprised by surprises. Maybe they'll be yawners.

solid copper 22. September 2008, 04:46

Good post, old man. Really good. :up: I did say hi to your parents. :smile:

Matthew 22. September 2008, 12:57

They already love the hospitality of Vancouver. I'm sure they'll be trying to find a way to move their retirement accounts to Canadian banks upon their return.

solid copper 22. September 2008, 13:14

Canadian banks are a lot more conservative, and that's why the effect of Wall Street is not too damaging this time around on this side of the border. And Vancouver is said to be an ideal place for retirees. The price for housing is reported to be dropping a little right now. It was on a steady climb for a long while. Prices in the Toronto area drop more sharply.

Matthew 22. September 2008, 13:19

They like Toronto as well. Are you on the national Tourism Board?

It's nice that Canada is, so far, relatively unaffected by the Wall Street meltdown. Markets around the world are not so lucky, including Russia, of all places.

Karen 22. September 2008, 17:35

Originally posted by Mr. Smarty-Pants:

Deja moo



Hahahaha :lol:





:faint:

Matthew 22. September 2008, 17:40

:wink:

Write a comment

You must be logged in to write a comment. If you're not a registered member, please sign up.

Download Opera, the fastest and most secure browser
January 2010
M T W T F S S
December 2009February 2010
1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31