Skip navigation.

People are aware of life when they are aware of death

~~Princess of Death

Twilight Movie Critique

, , , ,


First of all, this poster was too much photoshopped. It would have been okay if that was what they really looked like in the film... apparently.. they didn't.

Okay, so the movie has been out (after months of excited waiting)... and my one word description of the film after watching it? SUCKISH! I was even embarrassed that I promoted the film in the beginning. The movie sucks big time! The production itself didn't have a big budget which became a factor why I dislike it. Some people who haven't read the book said that the movie was awesome... HELLO! READ THE DAMN BOOK AND RENEW YOUR DEFINITION OF AWESOME! Let me enumerate the reason'S' why I absolutely detest the movie.


  • First of all, I detest the movie because it didn't give the book any justice AT ALL! I hate to think that a great book such as twilight turned into such a suckish movie.
  • The casting. IT SUCKS BIG TIME! Well, I know that there can't be any person in this world who can protray 'the' Edward Cullen, but I wish they could have chosen someone better. Robert Pattinson is a good actor, but not for Twilight. As for Kristen Stewart, her acting sucks. Well, not really bad, but her acting isn't Bella at all. Even when she said she's not afraid of Edward, she still looks scared. As for Nikki Reed (Rosalie), they should have chosen a prettier and a real BLONDE. Her depiction in the book is the most beautiful creature in the face of the planet for pete's sake! But Nikki Reed still passes for me. Jackson Rathbone was really okay for the role of Jasper. And I didn't dislike him at all in the movie (although he is very funny). I've got nothing to say to Elizabeth Reaser (Esme) except for the fact she looks too old for the role and Kellan Lutz was pretty okay too. Other than that, I give two thumbs-up to Ashley Greene (Alice Cullen), Cam Gigandet (James), Rachelle Lefèvre who played Victoria (although I wish her hair was redder than that), Edi Gathegi (Laurant), and Peter Faccineli (Dr. Carlisle) who were perfect for the role given to them. As for the human roles... I am satisfied.
  • Another factor why the movie sucks is because most of the cast haven't even read the book! I have watched interviews, sneak-peaks, and behind the scenes and it was pretty much obvious they don't know much about the story other than the stuff written on their script.
  • The effects. My GOODNESS! Cheap tricks and bad stunts. Hello?! It's already 2008! They should have provided better effects than that! And the way Robert Pattinson was climbing a tree? It was sooo OBVIOUS that he was being pulled up! It would have been better if they just pulled him at a pace a normal climber would then fast-forward it. Robert's arms barely caught up with the way he was pulled up while Kristen was on his back.
  • The CULLEN house. I expected a more grand/wider/bigger/BETTER house. The house depicted in the book wasn't like that at all.
  • The lines and scenes. There are a lot of reasons why people LOVE the Twilight Saga. One major factor/reason is the awesome and romantic lines Edward Cullen says to Bella Swan. Another are the awesome and thrilling love scenes. In the movie, you wouldn't appreciate Edward's love to Bella that much. (But I forgive the movie producers for this one. It will be hard to put every single scene and lines in movie that runs in less than 3 hours.)
  • Bella's Lullaby. COME ON! It's a lullaby and Carter Burwell composition doesn't even sound like a lullaby! His version of Bella's Lullaby is awesome, but it just doesn't fit with the story. River Flows in You by Yiruma would have been a better choice, but I do understand that you guys prefer if Bella's Lullaby had it's own composition. Still, I am not satisfied of Carter Burwell's compostion for Bella's Lullaby.
  • The romance. Okay, it was pretty obvious that this movie is somehow a love story. But the feeling of love and romance between Edward and Bella can not be felt at the movie. In the book, you can't help it but be moved about the way they love each other. The feeling of how safe it is to love again and never to have the fear of getting heart broken. Knowing somebody will love you for an eternity..... (okay. I think I got carried away). The good thing is that the movie still showed the essence of comedy but in a different way.
  • The interpretation. I know it is basically impossible to make the movie exactly the same as the book. But the Catherine Hardwicke's interpretation of Twilight is just lame. You can find the true essence or meaning at the movie, but not feel it. Which is exactly the opposite of what it was suppose to be.
  • Some are wrong.. JUST SO WRONG! Like in one scene that someone criticized Bella's Truck? In the book, it was pretty much said that it was a good thing that her car didn't blend in badly in the crowd since the most decent car in the lot was a silver volvo (Edward Cullen's car).




“Having lost much of its bite transitioning to the big screen, Twilight will please its devoted fans, but do little for the uninitiated.”
-Rotten Tomatoes



Well, Rotten Tomatoes... I think you better rethink that statement. Based on my observation, people who haven't read the book say they like/love the film.

The overall opinion seems to be that ‘Twilight’ has lost a little magic in the transition from book to film!
-Sugarlasm



A little magic? A LITTLE?! Are you kidding?!



I have a lot more to say about the movie. The producer's are lucky that the movie made $70.6 Million Dollars on its opening weekend. Probably the movie would have been great if I haven't read the book yet. As for me, the Twilight Movie is a BIG disappointment and I would recommend all those Twilight movie fans who haven't read the novel.. to FREAKING READ THE BOOK! It's 4000x better! If you like the movie, you'll absolutely LOVE the book!

As for those who hasn't seen the movie... FORGET ABOUT IT! JUST READ "Twilight" by Stephenie Meyer.

I am hoping the next movie will be better, but I am sad because the highlight of this series was the first book - Twilight.


~karen

How to destroy the EarthChinese Laughing Song

Comments

Moesring 8. December 2008, 08:48

You might be interested in seeing Metacritic's rating of Twilight. Some of the reviews and user comments they collated - particularly the really low ratings - seem to agree with you. :up:

:sst: Of course, some of the reviews they obtained are from movie critics, rather than Twilight fans, but the page might give you more ammunition. :devil:

ɥʇɐǝp ɟo ssǝɔuıɹd 8. December 2008, 09:51

I've had mosquito bites that were more passionate than this undead, unrequited, and altogether unfun pseudo-romantic riff on Romeo and Juliet.



Cruel.. but right. The romance in the book wasn't properly shown in the movie.

Lenard 8. December 2008, 16:05

Nice you are a certified bloger:up: :up:
I'm just wondering how you puT images into blog,. Can u teach me how...? :confused:

ɥʇɐǝp ɟo ssǝɔuıɹd 9. December 2008, 09:51

What kind of images? For the post? the layout and design? Or the photos in my album?

Kevin 9. December 2008, 12:52

turuan mu ko gumawa ng blog

VIEtchface 9. December 2008, 13:10

yes. i noticed that too. a lot of things were changed. oh well. i understand what u feel but im sorry, i cant agree with ya saying that Robert Pattinson didn't suit his role >:D i like him, there could be other guys around there but im olredi contented with him as Edward Cullen!


ɥʇɐǝp ɟo ssǝɔuıɹd 9. December 2008, 13:36



*drools*

I have to admit.. there are times when he does look like an Edward Cullen... but not most of the time.

Anonymous 9. December 2008, 23:59

patz writes:

totally agree with you...

the movie sucked, the girl wgho played bella sucks...

i fell for carlisle rather than edward

Winter 13. December 2008, 17:31

Heh well I would say otherwise P:

Movie wasnt that good as the book, but it did not suck, its a really strong word :smile: Of course, for Twilight fans who read every book in the saga, and have almost memorized all the lines, well you shouldnt probably be watching the movie at all :smile: A movie version of a novel is bound to be quite different, since it cannot completely follow the flow of the novel. The movie also kinda changes the image you have for those fictional characters.

I would say the movie is pretty good for first timers, for people who have not read the book and proceeded to the movie right away. Yes, there are a lot of modifications in the movie that I'd spotted, but those were just minor details. The Twilight book one was a very long story, cant expect everything in it to be included in the movie. Robert Pattinson wasnt that bad :D and I totally liked the other characters as well.

In short, its a nice relaxing romance movie, with a bit of humor and action, but not diverting too far away from the main focus that is Edward and Bella :smile:

ɥʇɐǝp ɟo ssǝɔuıɹd 14. December 2008, 15:17

Well, that's a nice perpective and comment. Interesting, although I had already considered that fact. They should have alteast made the movie better for the fans. I mean.. isn't that the reason why they made the movie? Because we made it famous?

Anyways, I already know that first timers adore the movie.

But there are still a few newbies on the saga who absolutely hate the movie, and will never read the book.

That is why I am so mad. My best friend didn't read the book, but watched the movie w/o my knowledge. All of the sudden, she told me she hates the movie and will NEVER read the book no matter how much I tell her that the book is just awesome.

And if the movie is that great, how come they fired Hradwicke (the director of Twilight)?

We all have different opinions about the movie, but this is my say about the matter at hand. I do respect your views, so do not misunderstand.

Winter 15. December 2008, 17:00

Ah well, I dont know why they fired the director. The movie was number one in the box office anyway.

But well, some people are just too critical and skeptic. Maybe your friend is one of them? No offense P: Nowadays, its pretty hard to find real love...so lets just enjoy what the movies can provide us with :wink:

Anyway, Im never a hater of any movies or books, I'm either neutral or interested :D and you're right, everyone has his/her opinions, I respect your views too :wink:

ɥʇɐǝp ɟo ssǝɔuıɹd 16. December 2008, 13:14

Well, the movie was actually okay... maybe the reason why I actually criticized it was because I was very disappointed about the fact that the movie wasn't as great as the book. Saddened by the fact the movie watchers won't be able to appreaciate the story the same way we twilight readers do.

Maybe I am trying to destroy the movie and persuade people to read the book instead... either way, I know most of the stuff I posted about the matter was true, but as the old saying qoutes: "No one is perfect".

VIEtchface 18. December 2008, 02:06


That is why I am so mad. My best friend didn't read the book, but watched the movie w/o my knowledge. All of the sudden, she told me she hates the movie and will NEVER read the book no matter how much I tell her that the book is just awesome.


~~~~~~

i have this close friend who hated the movie as well but of course it's my job as a fan of the book to force her to read the book [hahahaha] but like ur friend she doesnt want to! i figured out later that she was just using the never-read-the-book-because-the-movie-sucked excuse for her laziness to read!!! grrr!!

ɥʇɐǝp ɟo ssǝɔuıɹd 18. December 2008, 05:33

hAHAHAHAHA... i KNOW HOW YOU FEEL. well, my friend isn't much of a book worm, but still reads s few books. Even up to now, I am convincing her to read the book.

VIEtchface 18. December 2008, 05:38

:cheers: goodluck on that hime-san! hahaha! i hope that ull be able to convince her >:D

and by the way is it true that Jacob's character in New Moon will be played by another actor?

ɥʇɐǝp ɟo ssǝɔuıɹd 18. December 2008, 12:03

I've heard those rumors.... but I have no other news of for the next movie except for the fact that they fired the director of twilight and the new director will be Chris Weitz, director of American Pie, About a Boy, and The Golden Compass.

I think this time the production and movie will be better this time. And I hope they will give a bigger budget for New Moon seeing how much money they earned from the 1st movie.


CLick here to see more details about the casting of Jacob Black for New Moon

VIEtchface 18. December 2008, 12:17

>:D oh snaps! TAYLOR cant be as perfect as he is in the book but they should at least be a bit considerate! its not ryt to just go changing the actors/actresses! and besides i think Taylor is prety cute! wahahha!

~~~~

im so sure New Moon wll be a lot better!

ɥʇɐǝp ɟo ssǝɔuıɹd 18. December 2008, 12:44

Yeah.. the casting isn't that good (ex: the mai characters), but it will really be weird if they do change it. Another impostant issue is that they are prolonging the making of the movie. Edwarc Cullen doesn't age (according to the book) and Esme already looks old in the movie... If they don't hurry up, they will really be forced to change the cast.

VIEtchface 18. December 2008, 12:49

ooh yeah! New Moon will be out on theaters on 2010! thats gona require me a lot of patience!!! so i hope its worth the patience!!!

i didnt like the way Taylor Lautner looked with his shaggy long hair but he's cute with his hair short haha!

ɥʇɐǝp ɟo ssǝɔuıɹd 18. December 2008, 12:53

Hahaha... well if they follow the book, they will cut his hair soon. P:

VIEtchface 18. December 2008, 12:56

lol! haha yes! i suddenly remmbered this part when Jacob told Bella why he likes his hair shaggy and long, its because he thought that Bella likes it better that way! hahaha! and Edward was just probably evil laughing at his stupid thought!

Kitty 12. February 2009, 13:19

Thanks for directing me here, and thanks for the review. Nice read! :up:

Anonymous 22. July 2009, 19:37

Anonymous writes:

I really live this word "I feel very protective to you" wow wow ! if someone said with me ...hahahha

Anonymous 25. August 2009, 15:21

Anonymous writes:

i totally agree..when i read the book i felt taken away..few books had that effect on me. but the movie is just far away from the book. i just wanna know why did they do it this way..it could have been much much better...DOMMAGE

Anonymous 25. August 2009, 21:27

nothingness writes:

i have read the book and just three words I LOVED IT!!! haha i mean it was just so amazing. like every other girl i loved the romance. i watched half of the movie then stopped i was so disapointed so im excited for new moon

Anonymous 4. September 2009, 03:26

pooo... writes:

i red the comments been put up here....u know its not really possible to potray every element of a novel into a moviee...its easy to imagine things n put up on paper than enact the same in reality.....

the movie wasn that bad......i kinda fallen for it....charecters were nice, n i want to tell u guys my opinion abt one particular point of the movie...when bella says she is not afraid, however she looks....its perhaps cos the fact that she wanted to come close to edward, didnt want to loose him but at the same time was uncertain abt the intensity of his thrust for her blood.....that she even had mentioned in the next scene abt the 3 +ve things.....


overall....it was an awesome one for me......waiting for new moon egerly......

ɥʇɐǝp ɟo ssǝɔuıɹd 4. September 2009, 14:59

well, the problem is that the whole story itself isn't that amazing.. it's the romance that's amazing.. which wasn't quite well shown in the movie. the director didn't try to know what the reader's loved about the book.

Anonymous 16. September 2009, 11:36

jigme writes:

ohh ma gawd,
i am big fan of edward..i hav read all the buks but i didnt watch the movie..i have seen edward picture in ma friends cel n i really hav crush on him..i am edwardmania.............
lov bells

Anonymous 6. November 2009, 16:03

tsering writes:

i m big fan of twilight and eager 2 watch new moon

How to use Quote function:

  1. Select some text
  2. Click on the Quote link

Write a comment

Comment
(BBcode and HTML is turned off for anonymous user comments.)

If you can't read the words, press the small reload icon.


Smilies

Download Opera, the fastest and most secure browser
December 2009
S M T W T F S
November 2009January 2010
1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31