Skip navigation.

Allan´s Weblog

My message in a bottle

On Health Care

, ,

I understand that there's much talking in the USA about a health care reform.

There have been mentions of this on the weblogs of several regular readers of Allan's Weblog, since there are quite a few regulars from United States. I have tried to leave my comments as I could best - but have had severe difficulties doing so, since a straight comparison between the US and the Scandinavian (European?) system seems almost impossible. The differences are so manifest that it always seemed to be hard for me to make the point I really wanted to.

You see, I really think that our system has something to offer. Where I live, everybody has adopted different ways of doing things from USA. Particularly concerning cultural issues. I honestly think that the US could learn from us in health care matters.

Now, here follows a clip from CNN, which explains some essential differences (those differences I couldn't explain) between the two systems.

My wife and I are daily users of Danish health care, so I know a lot about this seen from the inside. From the user's point of view.



If you have questions, US citizen or not, don't hesitate to ask. I am here to answer your questions.


43 ThingsSneeze

Comments

WillYum 24. August 2009, 10:54

Excellent information, thanks for the link. Though, the hard numbers are interesting they are a *touch* misleading because it could simply indicate that the Danish are more healthy than our society... and considering how unhealthy those in our society can be, that's not too hard to imagine.

Nonetheless, it's a striking comparison and the point that we should learn from others is one that seems to be lost on many.

Yum

der Wandersmann 24. August 2009, 13:02

With my luck, I'd probably get 0.6 doctors.

LOL

Thanks, Allan ... but with me, you're preaching to the choir.

muse 24. August 2009, 16:21

I really think the system for health care that ya'll use makes a lot of sense, I admit to being quite jealous of you scandinavians and your healthcare. :smile: Of course, I do sincerely wish that you didn't need to make use of it Allan and you and yours could claim no knowledge of the system becuase you've never been sick :smile:
I think the barrier to that kind of health system in American is going to prove to be our cultural? stubborn independence rather than the common sense of it.

Angeliki 24. August 2009, 17:23

I actually did watch this program.
I live in the USA.
I want to point out that Lou makes a point with out including all the facts!
The medical cost per person in the USA it is higher because salaries of the doctors are higher, medicines cost more, millions of illegals do go to our emergency rooms and get free medical care.
Those expenses are added in our bills as well...
So, why European doctors move to the US and want the salaries of the American doctors and not what they made in Europe? how many million of people without medical insurances does Denmark take care?
If Denmark had additional 100,000,000 uninsured was the government going to handle the health care of the country?
Why so many illegals you might ask... that is something that
makes our schools over crowded, our taxes higher, our crime higher and it is a problem that started close to a century ago and it never ends!
Before we compare we have to see the similarities and the differences........

Is the USA in a position to brag about it's Health Care? no it is not! But the problem is not to be solved by getting advace from countries that do not face the same challenges..
and I will leave it @ that :smile:

thanks for sharing Allan,
the more we talk the more we can make things clear and that's always a good thing! :smile:

WillYum 24. August 2009, 19:58

Please cite from any legitimate source the statement "millions of illegals do go to our emergency rooms and get free medical care"

Edward Piercy 24. August 2009, 20:01

Allan, I was wanting to ask: Would Denmark invade the U.S.? Please? I really want the Danes to come here and throw us under their "despotic" sytem. Seriously. I would throw down my rifle (or camera) and surrender immediately.

Seriously. I'll even wave the flag at the Queen and such if you really want me to. Who cares as long we get a sensible system here.


And now I have a favor to ask, I'm afraid, I hate to ask but ---- Could I borrow a band-aide?



Angeliki 24. August 2009, 20:25

why Ed: "Could I borrow a band-aide?"
isn't America paying your medical bills?

Allan 24. August 2009, 20:26

Answers to questions:

Are the Danish more healthy than the US citizens? I do not know - but I don't think there are significant differences. Here, the more education, the more healthy, statistically. I guess the same goes over there?

How many uninsured does Denmark take care of? Well, 5,5 million - which is the total of the population. We don't need insurances - even though some have additional benefits coming from insurances, but these are just marginal numbers. You can have better food while staying in hospital, better general conditions - I guess you could call it luxury - which does not really affect the quality of treatment.

Why do European doctors move to the USA? In order to earn more, or because they met a wonderful spouse there, or something entirely different.

What if Denmark had an additional 100,000,000 illegals? Well, in that case there would live 105,500,000 people in the country total, and would have to sleep in layers. We have illegals here as well, you know.

Can you borrow a band-aide? Yes!

Would Denmark invade the USA? No, the vikings tried that, and didn't really succeed. But we are good at building bridges!


Angeliki 24. August 2009, 20:36

PS
Ed,
it is extremely sad that young people like you nn medical care,
however I feel it is even more sad that people with major health problems loose their homes to medical bills and die without being able to receive care.

I am not and American born but I will not put this country into mud.

there are disable people that receive disability and medical care. America is not perfect but not as bad as many believe it is!
If this is the case,
I wonder why many still want to move to America?

Angeliki 24. August 2009, 20:38

Originally posted by ricewood:

Why do European doctors move to the USA? In order to earn more, or because they met a wonderful spouse there, or something entirely different.




I will go with the entirely different,
they call it greater income

Allan 24. August 2009, 20:41

Nobody here, and certainly not I, is putting USA in the mud. If anyone is getting that impression, it is beyond me. I am the fiercest critic of Denmark around, which shows reading just a few posts back on this here weblog.

Criticizing my country is done out of love to my land. Trying to give good advice to others is done from a sincere wish to help - the same way the US of A has helped my country back in the day.

Edward Piercy 24. August 2009, 20:48

@ Angeliki.

I think I'll just let Allan handle this one. Before I blow my stacks.

Angeliki 24. August 2009, 20:48

I am sure you are not Allan,
I am also eager to see posts on things that are great in America..
Somehow I don't see many of those posts (and I am not talking about you in either case).

Allan 24. August 2009, 21:02

"Where I live, everybody has adopted different ways of doing things from USA. Particularly concerning cultural issues"

The above taken from this entry. That is saying something great about USA. I am writing this on a Mac, listening to rock and roll. Both originating from USA. I spent a significant part of my childhood reading about Donald Duck and his adventures. My brother looked like Elvis Presley for almost a decade.

The list never ends.

Seriously criticizing USA is a symptom of respect. Please note that I make fun of North Korea - since I think they are out of reach.

I am glad you say that you don't think I am dragging your country of choice through the mud, Angeliki. I wouldn't dream of doing so. I admire the stuff it stands for - as well as I can see that your country needs improvement, like any other country I know of.

I hope this helps :wink:

Angeliki 24. August 2009, 21:10

Originally posted by ricewood:

I am glad you say that you don't think I am dragging your country of choice through the mud, Angeliki. I wouldn't dream of doing so. I admire the stuff it stands for - as well as I can see that your country needs improvement, like any other country I know of




I do love America.
I chose to live here.
My birth place, which is Greece ,
lacks in many things as well.
I just make my statement as an American citizen numerous times when I feel that comparison with European countries it is not possible! I lived in both ends and know for sure what Lou did in his program is just to have more viwers .

der Wandersmann 24. August 2009, 21:11

Originally posted by edwardpiercy:

I would throw down my rifle (or camera) and surrender immediately.

I would not throw mine down; I have too much respect for fine equipment. I would carefully set them down on a non-marring surface.

The rest? Yeah! It'd be fun learning Danish.

Edward Piercy 24. August 2009, 21:15

@ derWandersmann

Oh, but those Danish articles and pronouns! Yikes!

:D

Allan 24. August 2009, 21:20

"Oh, but those Danish articles and pronouns! Yikes!"

You should talk!

Edward Piercy 24. August 2009, 21:21

Yeah, but I already know the English articles and pronouns.

LMAO.

Allan 24. August 2009, 21:24

I can tell you one thing - the Danish spoken numbers are impossible for anybody but Danes.

As an example, "50" is said, literally translated:

Half-three-times-twenty.

Beat that! :D

PainterWoman 24. August 2009, 21:26

An interesting article here from WorldNetDaily regarding Arizona.

Shoot, the link didn't work. Will have to find it again.

Edward Piercy 24. August 2009, 21:30

I got out a calculator and tried crunching the numbers several different ways but still couldn't arrive at 50 out of that.

No, can't beat it.

PainterWoman 24. August 2009, 21:34

I still couldn't get the link to work. Here is part of the article:


Court: State must cover care for illegals
By Jon Dougherty
© 2009 WorldNetDaily.com

“The Arizona Supreme Court has rejected a plea by the state's Medicaid provider to limit medical coverage for illegal immigrants to emergency room and acute care.

The Arizona Health Care Cost Containment System, or AHCCCS, manager of the state's Medicaid program, is obligated to provide care to illegals beyond emergency room and other acute care wards, justices ruled unanimously Thursday.

According to Capitol Media Services and the Arizona Daily Star, AHCCCS – which currently pays $75 million to $80 million a year in emergency care for illegals – had refused to reimburse hospitals for services it said were not covered. About one-third of that amount is covered by state taxpayers; the federal government covers the rest.

...”

Allan 24. August 2009, 21:34

@Ed:

It's like when we say that the time is five thirty. That's also called "Half six". Three times twenty is sixty. Fifty is then half-three-times-twenty.

I told you it was tricky.

Allan 24. August 2009, 21:37

@ Pam

Interesting indeed! Thank you.

Stardancer 24. August 2009, 21:46

It wouldn't bother me much if our health care was like the Danish system.

Originally posted by ricewood:

How many uninsured does Denmark take care of? Well, 5,5 million - which is the total of the population. We don't need insurances - even though some have additional benefits coming from insurances, but these are just marginal numbers. You can have better food while staying in hospital, better general conditions - I guess you could call it luxury - which does not really affect the quality of treatment.


But that's not what our Congress is trying to do. Our Congress is trying to force all Americans to pay for health insurance.

INSURANCE.

If the government were actually trying to make the care itself affordable for all Americans, I would support that. But forcing the purchase of insurance will do nothing but increase the costs of health care, which will eventually only increase the costs to each and every American, insured or not; and it will give the government or some insurance company executive the power to decide if treatment is cost effective, and make decisions as to what treatment people can actually receive.

I don't support that.

No way. No how.

Angeliki 24. August 2009, 21:48

Originally posted by PainterWoman:

According to Capitol Media Services and the Arizona Daily Star, AHCCCS – which currently pays $75 million to $80 million a year in emergency care for illegals – had refused to reimburse hospitals for services it said were not covered. About one-third of that amount is covered by state taxpayers; the federal government covers the rest.




I hope more states follow!
When I came to America with a suitcase full of used clothes and not a penny in my pocket,
I worked 2 jobs to make a living,
now days I might be in a much better financial condition, but my taxes are so high it is a crime!
All because funds needed to pay for housing, welfare,medical care of lazy people, illegals and people that don't even bother to vote for a change!
I want to make it clear :
I am not getting personal here with any body,
but I wish i had financial help and health isurance that will cover me too!
Many take it for granted
I pay 760.00USD each month for coverage, and when I see people not appreciating the help they receive I am mad !
The system is used by many,
the health care will never be even close to the European Health care because every 2 seconds another illegal allien jumps the border to America!

Allan 24. August 2009, 21:54

Star, I understand. I don't see the logics in forcing someone to pay for an insurance - particularly when someone is everybody. Keep it cheap and lean - insurance companies need to earn money, the state doesn't.

Angeliki, I'd like to say that Europe has it's share of immigrants coming from Africa in crummy boats, too. I have no idea in what numbers compared to the US, though.

WillYum 25. August 2009, 00:12

Wow, at the risk of getting stuck in the mud I'm wading into.

The *vast* majority of uninsured (or underinsured) in the state of Colorado were legal US citizens or residents. In fact, other than acute emergency care, people not from the state of Colorado got *NO* additional treatment.

If Arizona is treating illegals, it's because of Arizona's laws. Colorado isn't so nice, unless you are bleeding out on the floor you can't even get into the ER without providing billing information so that they may bill you.

Here is a much easier fact to grasp.

I cannot afford healthcare coverage. Of my two roomies, one has coverage, the other doesn't. The one with pays $200 a month for basic coverage, no serious medical issues covered.

Anyone who believes this healthcare system ain't broke need only spend half an hour with me.

Yum

studio41 25. August 2009, 07:11

I just so admire the way you have had care for Lise! I appreciate how you have explained, if I may share here, that care comes and goes many times per day to assist her with her needs. Even, if she feels she must sleep longer, they will return, and this is such a special thing, such excellent caring for needs! Bravo to Denmark in this!!

Allan 25. August 2009, 07:37

You're right, Jill. And thank you for mentioning it.

The goal with the care is always to try accommodating to a life as close to "normal" life as possible. Everyone else decide for themselves when to go to bed and when to get out of bed. This applies to all things - like when and what to eat. In the garden or in the house. To be able to go downtown if she wishes so. So on and so forth.

studio41 25. August 2009, 08:35

Originally posted by ricewood:

to try accommodating to a life as close to "normal" life as possible

sounds like a positive philosophy... very affirming!

Joni 25. August 2009, 09:08

Watch "Sicko," Michael Moore's excellent documentary on the sad state of managed healthcare in the U.S. You can view it on YouTube I believe. We have 'socialized' libraries, police, schools. Why not healthcare? (After all, it's good enough for Canada, France, England, Cuba....) Because the medical and pharmaceutical lobbyists won't stand for it. That would remove their PROFIT.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sicko

Allan 25. August 2009, 09:11

Indeed, Joni. I have seen the movie, though. I guess it's biased - as most things are - but nevertheless enlightening.

How to use Quote function:

  1. Select some text
  2. Click on the Quote link

Write a comment

Comment
(BBcode and HTML is turned off for anonymous user comments.)

If you can't read the words, press the small reload icon.


Smilies