Skip navigation.

User Centered

Studying the design of everyday things

Posts tagged with "strange design"

Window Size vs. Content Visibility

, ,

Am I the only one that thought these: < > scroll selectors in this Visual Source Safe Option menu is a bit strange?

It's a case of window size vs. content visibility...and I say in this case, the tab visibility should have won out... there's just two small tabs tucked away in the scrolled menu, could they really not just expand the window out a bit further to accomodate them?


We know where your file is, but we're not going to help you find it

, , , ...


The thing I like about Opera is the transfer panel. It keeps track of all your downloaded items and no matter where they are on your file system, they're easily accessible. Staying "on task" (read this information, install this application, etc..) is easy in Opera. I'm engaged and focused on whatever I'm doing at the time.

Of course, the problem is that since it's so easy to "set it and forget it" (as Ron Popeil would say), I often don't know exactly *where* on my local drive I'm storing stuff. It's never a big deal, but it does lead to a mess of a file system if not monitored with diligence.

With that littering in mind, I've found that the desktop is a decent place for me to dump these "temporary" files (that's what the desktop is supposed to be for right?), like images I've downloaded for a blog post that I don't plan to keep around, or installation programs. But saving to the desktop in Internet Explorer (at least version 6- this post comes about as I'm in the process of installing version 7) has always been a headscratcher for me...
...I've never understood this dialog. If it's anywhere else on my computer, I can click this "Open Folder" button and get immediate access to it...it's even highlighted for me. If it's on the "desktop," Windows insists on stopping me dead in my tracks and sending me off on some tangent in search of it. If you must interrupt my task, could you at least provide a mechanism within that dialog to show my desktop? If you know it's on the desktop, why can't you provide the same level of service as you do when it's in a folder? Maybe change the "Open Folder" button to "Show Desktop" and highlight it on the desktop. What's with the "I'm not going to help you in this case" attitude?

And don't get me wrong, I'm a big fan of the Win-D shortcut, plus I've got the "show desktop" icon on my quick launch but even with those, I still feel like my process has come to a screeching hault. I have to close out the dialogs and get back to my desktop which can sometimes takes a while on slower computers to minimize all the windows that are open. This just seems like strange design decision to treat the desktop target differently than a folder- just let me get at my downloads with ease please.

Like peanut butter and chocolate- two great things come together at last.

, ,



...and by "at last" I really mean: "yet again."

I really hate moving my hands back and forth from the mouse to the keyboard. It's why I've spent considerable time learning keyboard shortcuts for all my favorite applications. It's also why I love mouse gestures so much. I don't favor the keyboard or the mouse, I favor whatever my grubby hands are currently controlling.

That's why I thought I would like the fingerworks touchstream LP keyboard. I've known several friends that have them, they report various degrees of success. Of course, the reason I never got one (besides the price) was because of the lack of tactile feedback of the keys, and the fingerworks keyboard faded off as a distant memory as I consider a keyboard without the number pad on the right to minimize the "travel" of my hand.



But my interest was renewed this afternoon when I found (via a totalfark post) the "Combimouse."

I can't imagine a stranger looking device that I'd want on my desk, but I would like to play around with it for a while. I looked at the video they have available. Once you get used to the fact that your hands moving around when they're typing, it seems like an interesting approach. I think I would probably "re-center" or "home" the right half when I wanted to start typing... I'm willing to bet it would be a reflex for me to move the right side back in tune with the normal keyboard layout. I'd be fine with that- just as long as I'm not physically picking my hand up and moving it all the time. I know, I know, I've written about this in the past, on other sites and forums and I always get the "stop being so lazy" comments... it's not about that at all.

There's a very brief, not too terribly profound usability study (from 2004) that they post on the website that indicates for mousing:

There was no significant difference between the CombiMouse and the traditional mouse.


...and in regards to typing:

As a keyboard, the CombiMouse performed well, but results showed that the participants were significantly faster typing with the traditional keyboard. This is not surprising given the fact that users had little practice with the new device.



Looks like an interesting approach, although I think the scroll wheel on the left side of the keyboard should be rotated 90 degrees- seems like an odd orientation for it. Oh- I also thought about gaming. Maybe not for first person shooters, but this seems like a "poor man's" nostromo-type thing.


And in conclusion, neither one of these devices might not be any good (afterall, fingerworks is already out of business according to their website). But I at least appreciate someone taking the time and effort to solve this...and I'll keep continuing to track it until someone gets its right.

The psychology of waiting

, , ,


I'm not a store designer, I just play one on television*...as such, I realize that these super shopping stores (Super Target pictured- courtesy of google) are pretty much set up with 10 million registers for the handful of weeks towards the tail end of the year. Unfortunately, the other 48 weeks of the year, this is the most depressing thing in the world to see....WHEN YOUR WAITING IN LINE.

There's registers as far as the eye can see. Idle resources dedicated to the engine of customer service lay untapped. And here I stand; jockeying that plastic divider for position on the slowly creeping conveyer belt. Overwhelmed by the vast array of gum and breath mints, all vying for the coveted title of "impulse buy" atop my pile of purchases.

I don't know, it's a toss-up for me: on the one hand, I know I'd shout "put in more registers!" On the other, I should be careful what I wish for- it's like rolling up to a ghost town.

Well, now that the silly-ness is over, I would be interested in how designers determine the number of registers to install, if they all actually get used, or if they just shotgun blast registers across the bow of the store because that makes it easier to dynamically adjust to where the shoppers are queuing up. I'd imagine it's a combination of those, but to me, it just looks like a big giant waste, in some cases, more frustrating (in the "look but don't touch", or "ignorance is bliss" kind of way).

In conclusion, someone remind me to go to Super Target on the busiest shopping day of the year. I want to see EVERY one of those registers being used. Whatever registers are not used, come Dec 26th or thereabouts, the furthest ones from the exits should be removed.

Wow- I really didn't think I'd get to typing that much on this one. I don't know if I'm happy about that or ashamed.


*You may remember me from "America's Funniest Shopping Traffic Flow Design Bloopers. It was on one of yer higher cable channels.

Most useful pockets ever

,


I've always wondered why infant/toddler jeans have pockets on them....I mean actual functioning pockets. Seems like a ton of wasted effort that could be saved by using a "pocket facade" (I just coined that, thank you very much). I suppose it's in case there are some keys to the 'ol stroller that need to be secured during naptime, or perhaps for smuggling an extra pacifier around (assuming you don't mind a little pocket lint on it)

I mean, the things only last like a week or so before they're too small. I'd rather we just saved the trouble and effort/cost of the pockets and roll the price savings in to the pair of jeans I'm going to buy next time.

I will admit though, I did put car keys in my kid's pocket on occasion. Because:
  • I dont' like carrying things in my pocket, and well, he's not worried about fashion
  • I wanted to make sure I never left without him :smile:



Now *that's* what I call convergence

, ,

A pen, a radio, and... ummmm a shredder?!? If only they could manage to include a waste basket to catch the shredded mess, then this would be the best convergent device EVER!
The Girl Tech Password Journal Jam 'n Shred Pen



(via Boing Boing,Shiny Shiny, and possibly several other "two repeated word" websites)

Now that global warming is upon us and all*...

, , , ...

Updated

..it's nice to see someone harnessing the power of the sun to relieve us from...well, the power of the sun.

Whether or not this solar powered fan (warning- as with all "as seen on TV" webpages, it's horrible) does in fact keep your car cooler is not something I really care about- after all *I* live in Minnesota. I know, I know- feel free to email me when January rolls around and you're wearing shorts, sandles and sipping on margaritas. We'll call it equal.

No- I'm more concerned with the weather stripping that accompanies this gadget. Is my understanding correct that you have to lay out the weather stripping on your window every time you want to employ this thing? Seems labor intensive and not very user friendly. That might be why you can hardly tell from the commercial that you have to use it (they only show it twice in the video and rolled up at the end of the commercial).

Anyway, still a funny, strange, heart-in-the-right-place type of gadget. I'd be curious if anyone is dedicated enough to lay down the weather stripping and mount this thing instead of just cracking a window on your way into the grocery store to just grab some eggs. Seems like too much trouble for a what is probably not that terribly large of a problem.

As an update to this post-kmaage points out an "AskTog" (great articles there BTW) article on child safety seats and the "out of site out of mind" of children in the backseat. Buried in the comments is this great quote that goes along with this post-


The simple solution is a system that automatically keeps the interior of the car cool without compromising security. A small solar panel providing electricity to the A/C fan, to keep the air circulating, is cheap and simple. It has the additional benefits of preventing cracked windshields, keeping the car bearable for when you enter it, and reducing gasoline consumption from running the A/C at maximum when you get into a car that feels like an oven. All of these benefits accrue to those without children or pets in the car.

I don't see any need for fancy controllers--the more sun that hits the solar cell, the faster the fan turns. Sunlight is an excellent proxy for heating of the car's interior.


*Or nature is cycling through another "hot spell" or there is no problem at all. Take your pick depending on your beliefs- but dangit man, it sure is hot out there.

In case your child didn't hear you the first time....

, , ,


Interesting (and somewhat redundant?) picture submission from Shell-
As near as I can tell:
  1. Don't put this bag over your baby's head.
  2. If you do, don't let your baby crawl around with it on.

Don't we pretty much cover the second warning with the first?

Run NORAD from the comfort of your mountain bike

, , ,


For the general officers that like to be situationally aware even while hitting the trails- now you can have access to all your major computer systems from the comfort of your mountain bike.

Ok, probably not. Maybe Jeff or some other avid mountain biker will chime in. I found this on Gizmodo today, the appropriately named, "RAM Mount" (appropriate because a)You look like you have horns or antlers or b)you will eventually ram into something)

Look- don't get me wrong here, obviously I'm all for helping users get things done, but there has to be a reasonable limit...and by reasonable, I mean not goofy.


This thing would make an elk envious. Would anyone ever consider mounting all this gear on your handlebars? What are you taking conference calls on your smartphone while out on the road? -have a penchant to get a second opinion on the map plotting? I can see wanting to see *a* map.. but both the plugger and the mapping device? I'm not into this scene, but I can't imagine this being useful for anyone and I'd love hear something to the contrary as to what three devices you need to have visible at all times (while riding anything with handlebars).

...and who would actually ride down the street let alone a bike trail with this thing strapped to your rig? I know anyone doing serious biking would be concered about this apperatus throwing off weight and getting caught on something, or just plain broken in the event of an ill-timed dismount. Again, I'm not exactly hip the the social norms here, but I'd imagine someone pulling up to the bike trail with this thing in tow would be the equivalent of some guy showing up at college party wearying a waist pack, phone w/clip attached to belt, same with a PDA and a Swiss Army knife to top it off.

Then again, what do I know? This could very well be the single greatest advancement in biking (of all sorts) in the last 20 years- feel free to set me straight.

wikipedia on NORAD

Shopping cart cholesterol in the passengerial artery

, ,


So this grocery store has this sidewalk right in front of it with a single entry/exit point for shopping carts...and it’s kinda steep at that. In this picture, you see a shopper exiting the point in question and the store exit is on your left. Not only does this creates a "blockage" trying to get in and out of there with your shopping cart at busy hours, but if you had parked over to the left side of the picture, it's kind of annoying to have to walk to a specific spot and have to turn back around. I don't know why this is so bothersome to me, it's really not all that far, but probably because every other store I've ever been to in my entire life has never had anything remotely this constricting... it's completely avoidable by simply placing more ramps along the curb.

Hand carriers and "Evil Knievel" shopping cart pushers are obviously immune, as they can choose the "Dukes of Hazzard" route and careen off the curb... assuming of course, they don't have eggs in their parcel or three weeks worth of groceries that would combust at the slightest jostle.

I’ve seen several folks precariously holding the cart contents as they’ve navigated the somewhat steep grade. It seems the fully loaded carts have the most difficulty. This further slows the traffic down to a less than efficient Los Angeles-esque crawl. I've personally been in a single file line of carts 5 deep waiting for someone to get down that ramp without spilling their four cases of Pepsi onto the pavement (they weren't successful). Instead of outfitting their carts with Jake Brakes for this downhill slalom, I would think it would be better to simply flatten this out a bit, no?

Why not throw your shoppers a bone and add more exit points and flatten them out?

The title is paraphrased from some comedian I heard once Dennis Miller talking about the blockage that people do when trying to get off an airplane…. they stand in the aisle “like human cholesteral in the passengerial artery.” It's always stuck with me....I can’t remember who to attribute it to though.