
Like most of my posts, this post is illustrating a corner case of design that often isn’t considered. In other words, it’s probably not going to effect a large number of people, but my goal (if you haven't noticed yet) is to take a good attempt and see if we can't make it better.
I was trying to find my way to a Stadium here in my home of Saint Paul MN to watch a
Saint Paul Saints baseball game. I fired up the homepage and clicked on the
”Directions” link and was slightly annoyed to see directions given to me according to where I’m coming from, a trend that's pretty common for pages giving directions.
On the surface, it's a good idea; something I
talked about doing before. They just happened to have a textbook illustration, complete with all the things you
shouldn’t do if you’re going to provide this to your customers.
The most important thing is that they do not provide the address of the stadium on the directions page. At all. Not even in the directions. It’s kind of hard to miss a stadium, so that alone might be forgivable.
The other oversight is where the “corner case” that I mentioned comes in to play. The site gives you directions based on what direction you’re approaching from…but you don’t know where the stadium is so how can you know the direction you’re coming from? If you’re coming from another city, it’s likely you’ll be able to guess what direction Saint Paul is relative to your approach, and if you're familiar with all the freeways in the city, you might have an easier time to figuring out which direction to approach from based on the freeways listed. But then you'd have to read each one to figure out exactly which of the four sets of directions would work the best.
They should have included the address on the directions page, as well as an small map showing the stadium to take this from a "good attempt" at user centered directions to a great one.
Bonus: the "
click here to see a map of Saint Paul" at the bottom of the page is completely worthless for finding the stadium. You have to cross reference it to the freeways and streets in the directions.
Bonus Bonus! The "
Still need directions?" link at the bottom bottom of the page links to somewhere (literally) in the middle of the US.