Switch: Week 1
Saturday, 26. April 2008, 15:42:07
Hello, from the Mac for the first time. I would like to share some experiences with you about my switch to Mac. Before buying my MacBook Pro I thought of posting several (like 10+) episodes about switching and problems I had to solve and thing I discover. However the switch was so fast and painless for that there is in fact not so much to write about. As well it makes almost no sense to list all what I discover as there really tons of small and big great features all over the system. I recommend to watch some of them at Apple Video Tutorials.
Why I switched?
There are several reasons why I switched right now. I planned my next computer to be Mac for quite a long time. I used Windows XP for very long time (since its release) and had an opportunity to use Vista on my brother's computer for about 2 months when he went to England for a while leaving his notebook at home. And I must say I was happy to return back to Windows XP. Vista felt simply like developer preview, not like something that should reach paying customers. As I see around me at the university only fans of MS have Vista installed. These are the guys considering 5 years old features high-tech just because they are aware of MS products and don't usually know anything about where the technology really is.
Let's sum it up:
Why I didn't want to switch
I'm primarily a Java developer and I already use Java 1.6 in some projects. In fact I don't like Apple for many reasons, but I really hate its silence about when Java 1.6 will be released on Mac OS X. Although Apple doesn't talk about future product releases, I guess there is no real reason why not to let developers know. Development of Java is open and everybody knows how Java 1.6 looks like as it's for long time available for Linux, Solaris and Windows. Apple (Steve Jobs) promised that Mac OS X will be a premier platform for Java development when they were desperate to attract developers to their platform which was almost extinct at that time.
Let's sum it up:
The switch cost
Well, the switch cost was surprisingly low. In fact I got the MacBook Pro at Saturday evening and in Sunday I had all current data transfered, organized photos in iPhoto, music in iTunes, movies in iMovie, developing Java projects in IntelliJ IDEA, continuing my diploma thesis in NeoOffice, preparing presentation in iWork and almost ready my first DVD with iDVD. There are still some data on backup DVDs I have to put on my MacBook, but I would like filter them and reorganize them which is really boring and I don't it right now.
I don't expect that everybody's switch will be so smooth. I guess it probably depends how much has Microsoft locked you to its closed technologies, how many legacy non-crossplatform you use, how much you play games etc. For me as Java developer using primarily IDE, OpenOffice and Photoshop (just for personal use) the switch was like a charm. The problem is however that for example Adobe has separate Mc and Windows versions of their products, so you have to re-buy what you already have. Fortunately there is a student edition of their packages which are really affordable.
The difference
I have to say I had already known something about Mac OS X prior buying it. I have played with it several times and also know something about the technology. However I was shocked how different Mac OS X and Windows really are. Windows looks like a framework to start building an usable work environment, while Mac OS X is well usable from the very beginning. I won't compare them here as from my point view the products are in vastly different class and categories.
Pros and Cons
I won't write much about this as you could write a book about it. The overall experience is incredibly positive. I finally understand why Apple has so strong customer base. There is simply no way back. But it's not made the Microsoft's way to lock you on their technologies/formats/protocols. It's simply done by user interface and user experience.
The only really bad news for me was that you can't use FileVault (home folder encryption) and Time Machine (backup) in the way it's advertised. Your data are backed up only when you log out and you can't use the cool Time Machine interface. So you have to choose between security with weaker backup experience or no security with all the Time Machine features. I have chosen the first one as data protection on a notebook is essential for me and I don't expect I will return often to older versions of my data. The problem is caused by the way data are encrypted and seems to be by-design, so I will have to wait at least until Mac OS X 10.6. Maybe ZFS might help with this.
I'm most impressed by results you get from iLife and iWork. With much less effort than in any software on Windows you get extremely good looking results - document, presentations, movies, DVDs, slideshows etc. The Windows-made stuff looks like being made by 5 years old retarded child compared what an average user can do on Mac. Another great feature is organization of photos to events in iPhoto. I won't write more as I would simply waste hours writing what I like about Mac OS X and software on it.
You have to try to know what Mac OS X is all about. When you read the feature list it maybe doesn't look much better than any other OS, but when you try it you will see that every point in the feature list helps you a lot and there are many things not listed. Can't be told, can't be shown, must be experienced.
Hardware Cons:
Hardware Pros:
Software Cons:
Software Pros:
Conclusion
The only bright side about Windows is that I don't have to use them any more. If you play games, Mac should not be your choice. If you want to create something starting from presentation, programming to making movies choose Mac, because Windows is really something that limits your potential and wastes your time. That makes Windows much more expensive than any Apple hardware. I wish I have done the switch sooner.
Why I switched?
There are several reasons why I switched right now. I planned my next computer to be Mac for quite a long time. I used Windows XP for very long time (since its release) and had an opportunity to use Vista on my brother's computer for about 2 months when he went to England for a while leaving his notebook at home. And I must say I was happy to return back to Windows XP. Vista felt simply like developer preview, not like something that should reach paying customers. As I see around me at the university only fans of MS have Vista installed. These are the guys considering 5 years old features high-tech just because they are aware of MS products and don't usually know anything about where the technology really is.
Let's sum it up:
- overall user interface of Mac OS X
- Spotlight, Time MAchine, FileVault, Dock, FInder, ...
- iLife
- terrible user experince with Windows Vista
- I had a very good desktop computer, but I needed a good notebook too
- Windows XP having almost no built-in useful features
- in the worst case scenario I can just install Windows
Why I didn't want to switch
I'm primarily a Java developer and I already use Java 1.6 in some projects. In fact I don't like Apple for many reasons, but I really hate its silence about when Java 1.6 will be released on Mac OS X. Although Apple doesn't talk about future product releases, I guess there is no real reason why not to let developers know. Development of Java is open and everybody knows how Java 1.6 looks like as it's for long time available for Linux, Solaris and Windows. Apple (Steve Jobs) promised that Mac OS X will be a premier platform for Java development when they were desperate to attract developers to their platform which was almost extinct at that time.
Let's sum it up:
- only developer preview of Java 1.6
- same things will probably occur also with Java 1.7 and others
- higher price (especially in the Czech Republic the prices are much higher than those in USA and much higher than competition)
The switch cost
Well, the switch cost was surprisingly low. In fact I got the MacBook Pro at Saturday evening and in Sunday I had all current data transfered, organized photos in iPhoto, music in iTunes, movies in iMovie, developing Java projects in IntelliJ IDEA, continuing my diploma thesis in NeoOffice, preparing presentation in iWork and almost ready my first DVD with iDVD. There are still some data on backup DVDs I have to put on my MacBook, but I would like filter them and reorganize them which is really boring and I don't it right now.
I don't expect that everybody's switch will be so smooth. I guess it probably depends how much has Microsoft locked you to its closed technologies, how many legacy non-crossplatform you use, how much you play games etc. For me as Java developer using primarily IDE, OpenOffice and Photoshop (just for personal use) the switch was like a charm. The problem is however that for example Adobe has separate Mc and Windows versions of their products, so you have to re-buy what you already have. Fortunately there is a student edition of their packages which are really affordable.
The difference
I have to say I had already known something about Mac OS X prior buying it. I have played with it several times and also know something about the technology. However I was shocked how different Mac OS X and Windows really are. Windows looks like a framework to start building an usable work environment, while Mac OS X is well usable from the very beginning. I won't compare them here as from my point view the products are in vastly different class and categories.
Pros and Cons
I won't write much about this as you could write a book about it. The overall experience is incredibly positive. I finally understand why Apple has so strong customer base. There is simply no way back. But it's not made the Microsoft's way to lock you on their technologies/formats/protocols. It's simply done by user interface and user experience.
The only really bad news for me was that you can't use FileVault (home folder encryption) and Time Machine (backup) in the way it's advertised. Your data are backed up only when you log out and you can't use the cool Time Machine interface. So you have to choose between security with weaker backup experience or no security with all the Time Machine features. I have chosen the first one as data protection on a notebook is essential for me and I don't expect I will return often to older versions of my data. The problem is caused by the way data are encrypted and seems to be by-design, so I will have to wait at least until Mac OS X 10.6. Maybe ZFS might help with this.
I'm most impressed by results you get from iLife and iWork. With much less effort than in any software on Windows you get extremely good looking results - document, presentations, movies, DVDs, slideshows etc. The Windows-made stuff looks like being made by 5 years old retarded child compared what an average user can do on Mac. Another great feature is organization of photos to events in iPhoto. I won't write more as I would simply waste hours writing what I like about Mac OS X and software on it.
You have to try to know what Mac OS X is all about. When you read the feature list it maybe doesn't look much better than any other OS, but when you try it you will see that every point in the feature list helps you a lot and there are many things not listed. Can't be told, can't be shown, must be experienced.
Hardware Cons:
- lid does not touch the bottom part of notebook in the corners
- exchanging hard drive can be quite a challenge
- really hot when encoding video
Hardware Pros:
- LED backlight
- GeForce M8600
- touchpad
- size
- aluminum enclosure
- great keyboard + illumination
- magnetic power cord
- adapter size and roller solver
- remote control
- slot-in DVD drive
- 6-pin FireWire 400 and FireWire 800
- dual-link DVI
- WiFi draft n
- minimalist functional design
Software Cons:
- not final Java 1.6
- can't use combination of FIleVault + TimeMachine in the advertised way
- had to restart twice, because the system simply got very slow and I was unable to determine why
- failed to wake-up when the lid was closed in Front Row
Software Pros:
- easy to setup Mac OS X
- overall usability and look-and-feel
- great looking results in iLife and iWork with minimal effort
- Spotlight, FileVault, FInder (Sharing), Dock (Stacks), ...
- ... to long to write - you have to try it
Conclusion
The only bright side about Windows is that I don't have to use them any more. If you play games, Mac should not be your choice. If you want to create something starting from presentation, programming to making movies choose Mac, because Windows is really something that limits your potential and wastes your time. That makes Windows much more expensive than any Apple hardware. I wish I have done the switch sooner.
