More testing: Updated EV information and new Roots
Friday, 18. April 2008, 18:22:12
A few hours ago the new online certificate repository that the most recent weeklies are using was updated with several new roots, and an additional CA, Comodo, was also provisionally EV-enabled
The new and the updated CAs are
There is no need to download an updated Weekly (if you have one of the two recent ones). When you next restart one of the Opera 9.50 Weeklies with support for online certificate updates, it will immediately download the indexes, and download the new certificates when necessary. Please give it a minute to finish the update.
Here are a couple of testsites:
Known Issues: The complex certificate chain system used by Comodo encounters some, mostly hidden, problems with our OpenSSL certificate verification support, and that will cause some EV sites to not be recognized. We will try to fix it, but it may not be advisable to include a fix in 9.50.
[*] DigiCert:
I do not currently have testcases for Cisco, as they have not yet started issuing certificates from the new root.
More about known issues:
The new and the updated CAs are
- America OnLine
- Cisco
- Comodo
- Digicert
There is no need to download an updated Weekly (if you have one of the two recent ones). When you next restart one of the Opera 9.50 Weeklies with support for online certificate updates, it will immediately download the indexes, and download the new certificates when necessary. Please give it a minute to finish the update.
Here are a couple of testsites:
- AOL: https://new.aol.com/ . This site will verify in newer versions, but not in older (Warning about issuer). Known problem: The security level is low due to problems with the CRL (Unsupported format, and currently no plans to support it. The connection will fail in the first build). AOL is aware of the problem, and was already working on updating their CRL system
- Comodo EV sites:
-
https://www.sslcertificaten.nl/
-
https://comodocertificationauthority-ev.comodoca.com/
-
https://secure.comodo.com/example.html
Known Issues: The complex certificate chain system used by Comodo encounters some, mostly hidden, problems with our OpenSSL certificate verification support, and that will cause some EV sites to not be recognized. We will try to fix it, but it may not be advisable to include a fix in 9.50.
[*] DigiCert:
-
https://vpn.osrmedical.com/Citrix/AccessPlatform1/auth/login.aspx In older versions this will validate to an Entrust root (see in the Certificate details view of the security toolbar dialog), after this remote update of 9.50 the root will instead be "Digicert High Assurance".
-
https://www.iwanttss.com/ In older versions this site will trigger an unknown issuer warning, after this update it will also validate to "Digicert High Assurance"
I do not currently have testcases for Cisco, as they have not yet started issuing certificates from the new root.
More about known issues:
- We know there are some problems with OCSP and CRL responses (the two kinds of revocation information) from some Certificate Authorities. These problem may lead to the website getting a lower security level. We are looking into these problems together with the CAs. In last week's build some of the CRL problems will cause a "Fatal Error 50", in the most recent build that has been fixed. We may decide to work around some of these, but they should preferably be fixed by the CA.
- At least one CA (who is not in our repository) is using CRLs with a critical extension, which will cause the secure connection to fail with error code 554. In this case we are following the standard, although one might wonder why the specification says "Although the extension is critical, conforming implementations are not required to support this extension". The problem have been "fixed" internally by recognzing the extension, then ignore it, as we do not need it.








hartley231 # 19. April 2008, 00:49
hartley231
Update: scratch that! Just tried https://brokerage.comdirect.de/ and I have a green EV background. Maybe something to do with the specific site?
yngve # 19. April 2008, 11:54
kloining # 20. April 2008, 20:57
yngve # 20. April 2008, 22:14
The currently EV-enabled CAs are only enabled provisonally.
oscardt # 21. April 2008, 21:24
In the security tab It says: "the connection to this server is secure"
and paypal uses EV
https://www.sslcertificaten.nl/ however does show green.
yngve # 21. April 2008, 22:56
Paypal is using content from sites that are not EV certificate, and as such the identity of all who created the content is not sufficiently proven.
See my articles for more information:
http://my.opera.com/yngve/blog/2008/04/08/new-in-kestrel-end-of-the-extended-validation-wait
http://my.opera.com/yngve/blog/2007/06/19/it-aint-ev-til-its-ev-all-ev
blinkybill # 22. April 2008, 13:39
When opening https://www.paypal.com/ here I get the grey ?
in the address bar. But if I then mask as Internet Explorer
then I get the lock with the yellow background.
Is this how it should be?.
cheer
blinkybill
yngve # 22. April 2008, 21:11
blinkybill # 24. April 2008, 13:25
Just updated to the new Opera 9.5 beta2 and still
www.paypal.com shows a grey ?.
I am using Windows XP SP2 and I installed Opera
using the Classic Installer.
I tried it at work with Opera and it shows the
Lock with the Yellow Background so I got no
clues as to why mine doesn't. Could this be
a bug somewhere?.
cheers
blinky
yngve # 24. April 2008, 15:11
This new feature performs a lot of extra data verification, and if one of them cannot be completed then the site won't get a secure indication.
blinkybill # 25. April 2008, 05:36
Here is a screenshot mate of the Grey ?.
http://img155.imageshack.us/my.php?image=paypalrv2.jpg
cheers
blinky
t1gershark # 26. April 2008, 11:51
https://banking.bw-bank.de/
security panel says, that there's no
secure connection available.
What's wrong ?
yngve # 26. April 2008, 15:37
t1gershark # 27. April 2008, 09:46
Reduced security level is good, but the panel says that
there's no security at all
blinkybill # 7. May 2008, 05:54
Just installed the latest 9.5 beta and now
www.paypal.com shows the yellow background
with the lock.
cheers
blinky
YinYanger # 2. June 2008, 11:42
Are you heard about PetName systems? Interesting reading!
http://www.skyhunter.com/marcs/petnames/IntroPetNames.html
Bye!